opinion
Ireland
1 Switzerland 0
Christian
Holland finds that Switzerland in the Med is an Irish joke
Irish Prime Minister Bertie Ahern's departure has left the chair
vacant for Prof. Anthony Coughlan to contradict him over Ireland's
recent prosperity. This musical chair politics has returned the
European Union to the front page yet again and provoked some likely
reactions form our politicians.
Whilst Alfred
Sant yodelled on, up the heady heights of a political wilderness
gone cuckoo, Eddie Fenech Adami danced an Irish jig to a blarney
tune. The Nationalist's answer to Switzerland finally materialised
in Ireland. And our P.M. could not restrain himself from some
simplistic comparisons, namely that both Ireland and Malta are
islands and both share strong ties to Catholicism. There were
loads more and were it not for the Irish P.M.'s short visit Fenech
Adami could have gone on and on. Both countries are ex-British
colonies and both suffered to a varying degree under British rule
resulting in large scale emigration to the New world. We both
like stout, they beer and we women. We both have an eye for potatoes
and we're both blighted by the smell of whisky. We've both got
Irish pubs, never won the world cup and are all Eurovision addicts,
bar Bondi that is. But more importantly we both have politicians
with completely divergent views on the benefits of the European
Union. So 'thar'.
Bad jokes
apart, our fears and expectations are very different to Ireland's.
And it would be foolhardy and dishonest not to accord some validity
to them. Ireland is practically underpopulated having, like Malta,
more sons and daughters scattered around the globe than living
at home. Yet unlike Malta, it can take them all back and still
have space for more. Its agricultural sector still employs one
of largest percentages of population within the E.U. In fact the
Irish have gained through the common agricultural policy. Our
agricultural sector is negligible. Ireland is in a situation where
it can welcome both capital and labour and it has lots of spare
capacity for development land-wise.
Malta is
at the other end of the scale bursting at the seams with people
and with approximately 23% of its surface area built up. The pressure
of competing land uses is tremendous. We are understandably sensitive
to foreigners buying up houses apart from the resulting price
inflation. The small size of our economy is susceptible to minor
tremors and any small influx of economic refugees is a big headache.
Ireland can absorb big industries with little consequence. We,
on the other hand, can only take big risks like sacrificing Birzebbuga
and Kalafrana for a transshipment industry in direct conflict
with our mainstay - Tourism. This industry is becoming increasingly
dominated by big international companies that can literally make
or break our economy. The E.U. may be an opportunity for Ireland,
for us it is opportunism, despite the denials.
One has only
to look at the marketing of the E.U. by the Nationalists and its
emphasis on money coming our way, and the chance for our children
who want out to get out. Ireland may end up being a full-fledged
Celtic Tiger. Malta, on the other hand, can play Tigger.
The energy
and dynamism of this administration to satisfy the requirements
of the Acquis are impressive to any observer. Yet this exercise
does not imbue the population at large with confidence or conviction.
If only we were to apply this same vigour to erase once and for
all the pitiful and disgusting habits of our culture - the sloth
of the public sector, the dereliction of our environment both
natural and built, the indifference to our children's education
and the insanity of our politics. Then we can be in a position
of true choice instead of hedging bets about our predicament.
The Irish
week will soon be over. Mr.Ahern, the Pied Bagpiper with his soothing
sound has bade us farewell and good luck with the European Union.
|