Back
Register for SMS Alerts
or enter your details manually below...
First Name:
Last Name:
Email:
Password:
Hometown:
Birthday:
Sorry, we couldn't find that email.
Existing users
Email
Password
Sorry, we couldn't find those details.
Enter Email
Sorry, we couldn't find that email.

Parties had every right to ask for division of property

Dispute arising between the parties was unfounded as the dividing lines were already clearly and precisely established in the contract

malcolm_mifsud
Malcolm Mifsud
17 February 2017, 8:00am
The Court concluded that the parties had every right to ask for the division of property
The Court concluded that the parties had every right to ask for the division of property
On the 7th February 2017, Magistrate Joanne Vella Cuschieri in the case Camilleri vs. Azzopardi et held that a co-owner possessing property adjacent to the land commonly owned with other parties, may demand such part of the latter property as is adjacent to the property already owned by him upon division of the property between them.

In this case, the parties jointly purchased an undivided plot of land in the limits of Nadur, Gozo. In a subsequent contract, many years later, this plot of land was duly divided into six portions, each party being assigned two plots of the aforementioned land. However, one small portion of this land was prohibited from being divided between the parties by the respective authorities and thus remained commonly owned between them. 

Although the dividing lines between these plots of lands were established in the aforementioned contract, a dispute arose between Camilleri and Azzopardi as to where the dividing lines were actually placed. They failed to reach an agreement as to the exact portion of land which had been assigned to the plaintiff and that assigned to the defendant. The plaintiffs thus argued that this should be determined by the Court in a clear and permanent manner. 

The Court, however, relying on the technical expert appointed by it, found that the dispute arising between the parties was unfounded as the dividing lines were already clearly and precisely established in the contract. The plea was dismissed on the ground that although the plaintiffs tried to settle this dispute in good faith, the defendants kept raising arguments without any good reason whatsoever. 

Furthermore, Camilleri et no longer wanted to remain in a state of common-ownership with the defendants, pleading to the Court to duly divide the remaining portion equally amongst all owners. The defendants argued that this was as yet undivided due to the fact that the government sought its ownership for development as a green area or in order to build a street in the public interest. 

The Court concluded that the parties had every right to ask for the division of property. Moreover, given the fact that the plaintiffs were previously assigned a plot of land adjacent to the land still commonly owned between them, it was argued that in terms of Article 503 they were entitled to that portion of the undivided land commonly owned adjacent to the plot of land already owned by the plaintiff. Having apportioned this part to the plaintiffs, the Court then assigned the remaining portion to the other parties in equal portions. 

The Court finally appointed Notary Dr Maria Vella Magro so as to ensure that the division of the remaining plot of land commonly owned between the parties takes place within a month from the judgment.

Dr Malcolm Mifsud is partner at Mifsud & Mifsud Advocates

malcolm_mifsud
Malcolm Mifsud is a partner at Mifsud & Associates.
DealToday
Latest Business News
Technology 08:04
A major global cyber attack disrupted computers at Russia's biggest oil company, Ukrainian banks and multinational firms with a virus si...
Business News 14:17
Looking for a high-paying job? Look no further than the Financial and Insurance Service sector where the average annual basic salary stands ...
Business News 12:23
The European Union has fined Google €2.42 billion for breaching competition rules in online shopping service
Business Comment 27-06
Monday was a positive day for European equities as they strengthened with gold tumbling to the weakest point in five weeks – maybe a r...
Business Comment 26-06
Brexit remains in the spotlight this week as Theresa May is expected to lay out her offer to fellow EU leaders for the rights of both Britis...