Back
Register for SMS Alerts
or enter your details manually below...
First Name:
Last Name:
Email:
Password:
Hometown:
Birthday:
Sorry, we couldn't find that email.
Existing users
Email
Password
Sorry, we couldn't find those details.
Enter Email
Sorry, we couldn't find that email.

Rubble wall serving no agricultural purpose refused

The Tribunal considered that the rubble walls served no agricultural purpose since the land was not cultivated

robert_musumeci
Robert Musumeci
21 April 2017, 7:30am
A planning application contemplating the sanctioning of the construction of a random rubble boundary wall including fixing of timber gate, was turned down by the Environment and Planning Commission (File photo)
A planning application contemplating the sanctioning of the construction of a random rubble boundary wall including fixing of timber gate, was turned down by the Environment and Planning Commission (File photo)
A planning application contemplating the sanctioning of the construction of a random rubble boundary wall including fixing of timber gate, was turned down by the Environment and Planning Commission. The said wall borders an agricultural tenement outside the development zone of Bahrija. In order to justify its decision, the Commission cited a number of reasons.

Primarily, the proposed sanctioning was not considered essential to the genuine needs of agriculture because the site was not characterised by agricultural land. Consequently, the proposal was deemed to run counter to Structure Plan policy AHF 5, which specifies that “only buildings and structures essential to agriculture will be permitted in the countryside.”

In fact, the site was characterised by garigue land, where, according to the PA, no human intervention is permitted. Moreover, the site in question was found to be located within a buffer bone for Archaeological Importance. The Commission thus insisted that the employed interventions (in building the boundary wall) could have an impact on “the character, integrity and value of features of cultural heritage importance.”

Finally, it was held that the employed construction methodology was not of the traditional type. 

In reaction, applicant filed an appeal before the Environment and Planning Review Tribunal, insisting that the Department of Agriculture never objected to his proposal. Applicant, now appellant, argued that most of the site was already covered with soil and went further to point out that he was “willing to deposit a bank guarantee to safeguard the site from an archaeological point of view.”

The case officer however held that the application was a third attempt to sanction an illegal development. The officer reminded the Tribunal that applicant’s site was located in an area scheduled as a Class A Buffer Zone for Archaeological Importance. 

It was further reiterated that the boundary walls failed to respect the topography of the site and the surrounding area and were hence considered not to be consistent and compatible with the characteristics of the site and the immediate surroundings. Finally, the officer pointed out that the site was characterised by cart-ruts, tombs and irrigation channels, whilst adding that the Superintendent of Cultural Heritage was concerned with the proposal. 

In its assessment, the Tribunal observed that, as held by the Authority, the site in question was located in an area of extraordinary archaeological importance. 

Moreover, the Tribunal considered that the rubble walls served no agricultural purpose since the land was not cultivated.

Against this background, the Commission’s decision was found to be correct and the appeal was consequently rejected.

Dr Robert Musumeci is an advocate and a perit 

robert_musumeci
Dr Robert Musumeci is a warranted advocate and a perit. He also holds a Masters Degree in ...
Latest Environment News
18:36
The 67-year old pensioner is indicted for murder of a father, 45, and his son, 24, after a heated argument ended in bloodshed
18:02
In his latest video-blog, MediaToday managing editor Saviour Balzan speaks about how Jean Pierre Debono's resignation from Parliament ca...
17:56
Ri Yong-ho said Pyongyang reserved the right to shoot down US bombers, including those flying outside North Korean airspace
17:10
Shinzō Abe aims to take advantage of opposition disarray and says vote would be an appraisal of his handling of North Korea crisis
16:58
The oil rig, which has been berthed at the Palumbo yard in Grand Harbour for over a year, has ruined the Grand Harbour view