Dalli accuses PN of apartheid-style management

EU Commissioner John Dalli insists the Nationalist Party has fallen prey to an apartheid-style intolerance which brooks no internal disagreement or dissent.

EU Commissioner and former PN minister John Dalli(right), with Bla Agenda presenter Norman Hamilton (left)
EU Commissioner and former PN minister John Dalli(right), with Bla Agenda presenter Norman Hamilton (left)

EU Commissioner and former Nationalist minister John Dalli has accused the Nationalist Party of allowing itself to be run by an intolerant "policy of apartheid where one either obeys, or one has no place there."

"That is not the Nationalist Party," he said, speaking on Norman Hamilton's discussion programme Bla Agenda.

Dalli insists that during his time within the Nationalist Party, he and many other Nationalists valued the freedom they enjoyed in being able to voice their opinions.

"I, like many other Nationalist, was always the sort of person who always used our heads and reserved the right to do so," Dalli said. "I was always protective of my right to criticise freely."

Dalli however dismissed attacks made in his regard by PN loyalists who accused him of rocking the boat in an attempt to assuage his resentment at being sidelined. "I will not be accused of disloyalty for criticising someone internally," he said categorically.

He insisted that disloyalty "is when one applauds those who do wrong despite being aware of it," and added that "those who unfailingly praise my successes are not friends."

"It is those who point out my mistakes who are true friends," he said however, "because they have my best interests at heart and want me to do better."

Dalli also insisted that "constructive criticism is vital and it should never be considered disloyalty and result in a 'death sentence'."

Dalli also spoke about his recent claims that his email account was hacked by individuals within the Nationalist Party, and a police investigation which began in July when Dalli provided a list of names to police investigators.

While reiterating that email accounts "belonging to me, friends, and family were hacked" Dalli said that while he had his suspicions regarding phone tapping, "I have no proof whether telephones were tapped or hacked."

He however expressed doubt whether the official police investigation into the email hacking allegations will bear fruit or uncover any perpetrators. "Today I don't think that there is any possibility that one arrives to the source of the hacking in a legal manner," Dalli said.

He hinted that the investigation may lose momentum or simply peter out due to a lack of political will to drive it forward. "This is because there is no will to ensure that what should be done, is done," he said.

Dalli however added that "I am capable of waiting" suggesting that the situation could yet change in the future.

Asked to comment about the ongoing parliamentary instability whereby government is being held hostage by rogue MP Franco Debono, Dalli opined that "parliament is not functioning."

"It is an essential institution which, in my opinion, is being disfigured," Dalli said. "It is harmful for the entire country."

He insisted that a government should put the individual at the centre of its administration, while however hitting out at those who thought that the individual's interests could be superseded by other considerations.

"I rebel against those who believe that they can think they can manipulate the individual as they wish," he said.

He also accused the government of turning its back on the manner in which Fenech Adami's administration approached wealth distributions.

He said that while Fenech Adami's administration generated large volumes of wealth and ensured its even distribution across society, he said the current administration is achieving exactly the opposite.

"Today, I'm seeing a 'funnelling policy' in effect, whereby wealth is being siphoned away from the population towards the few," Dalli said.

avatar
isma isma x qed nisma.......!!! u dan John Dalli mhux Guzeppi Muscat
avatar
Shame on you Mr Dalli. Now tell us how he distributed the Popeye Village wealth - a goldmine - way back in the late eighties. Sur Dalli, biex titkellem trid tkun pur!
avatar
I fully agree with xifajk. Once I was involved in a sensitive project and although Mr. Dalli knew precisely my political orientation he trusted me and I worked hard to succeed. This is what I call real management, outside the influence of politics, Mr. Dalli is a true gentleman and I have been saying this since the time that Mr. Dalli contested the PN leadership.
avatar
kos hux min ma jilhaqx l-enba jghid li hi qarsa.
avatar
@ il_mignun Lil mignun nghidlu: Tal-PL lil Dalli qed ihobbuh wisq anqas minn kemm il-partit tieghek (PN, GonziPN. ecc) habbu meta akkuzah b'affarijiet li ma kenux minnhom, gghaluh jirezenja minn ministru, u meta ridtu tinqdew bih lejliet l-ahhar elezzjoni ergajtu dahhaltuf fix-xibka. Sraqtu l-ahhar elezzjoni, ghamiltuh Ministru u malli giet l-ewwel okkazjoni dabbartulu rasu lejl Brussels (the proverbial "kick upstairs"). U ohra. Forsi veru jaf jigi zmien meta mhux kulhadd ikun jaf min Dalli verament hu. LILEK nghidlek: hares fil-mera siehbi u ara tarafx lil min hemm ihares lejk!
avatar
Il-malti jghid li l-giddieb ghomru qasir. Gonzipn gideb meta ghamel spin ta' dak li qal Joseph Muscat. Il-bierah il-kummissarju Dalli faqalu l-buzzieq. 1. Qallu li tul dawn l-ahhar 25 sena l-minimum wage QATT ma zdiedet hlief bil-Cola. 2. Jekk izzid il-minumum wage tkisser il-finanzi tal-pajjiz. Mela allura ghalfejn dal gideb kollu. Possibbli m'ghandhomx argumenti biex jikkonvincu lil poplu jivvutalhom. jghajkjru lil Dr Muscat li jekk ikun fil-gvern se jifqa l-finanzi (li huma tant mexxew tajjeb) imbaghad iriduh jgholli l-minimum wage. Anqas Tonio Fenech ma jaqbel li l-minimum wage tghola ghax fl-2010 tkellem fuq hekk f'wahda mil-laqghat tal-Hadd tal-PN. GIDDIBIN ma hemmx titlu iehor x'tista tghidilhom. U int ja poplu se terga tazzarda tafda dan il-pajjiz f'idejn dan-nies li biex jibqghu fil-poter jaslu jaghmlu kollox?
avatar
@il_mignun. Qisek mahruq habib. Ahjar tixtri fire extinguisher!
avatar
Wahda mill l ghar sqarrijiet l saru kienet ta Charlo Bonnici meta qal li kull kanditat nazzjonalista irid jiffirma sqarrija biex kull min ikun kanditat tal pn biex joqghod ghal ma jghid il partit. Dik demokrazija,dik dittatura.
avatar
Ajma kemm qed ihobbuk il-Laburisti illhum u kemm qed ituk titli sbieh fil-kummenti! Qalbhom perzuta saret ghalik Sur Dalli u ghal shabek l-ohra li ma jafux x'inhi lojalta' lejn il-Kap tal-Partit li qedghin fejn qedghin taht it-ticket tieghu. Kompli tieghom pjacir. Int bhat-tnejn l-ohra dalwaqt hadt ma jkun jaf min int! Jekk thobb daqshekk lil partit ghax ma ghamiltx bhal Simon u David...jekk BRUSSELL aktar attrajenti? In-nannu kien jghidli, "eh ibni, l-ewwel il-PAPPA mbaghad l-IMPAPPA!
avatar
Jekk kellna bzonn prova ta' kemm Lawrence Gonzi , Tonio Fenech , Beppe Fenech Adami u dawk kollha li qalu li Joseph Muscat se jiffriza il-Minimum Wage huma giddiebin , tali gidba ikkonferma il-Kummissarju Ewropej John Dalli li kien Ministru tal-Finanzi Nazzjonalista għall diversi snin meta qal , li il zieda tal-COLA ma għanda x'taqsam xejn ma-zieda tal-Minimum Wage . Qed taraw min hu giddieb hux , jekk hux Joseph Muscat jew Gonzi w il-bella kumpanija ta' madwaru .
avatar
...Dalli accuses PN of apartheid-style management. I can vouch for Mr John Dalli when he was Minister of Finance. Although Mr Dalli knew that I wasn't one of his supporters or a Natioalist he treated me with respect and when once there was a disagreement with a department's customer, he proved to be a gentleman and phoned me up to see how the disagreement occured. When Georeg Bonello Du Puis, Gonzi and Tonio Fenech were Ministers of Finance, they treated me like garbage, and I was eeven threatened abd Bullied by DGs and Directors and when I spoke up they didn't even had the balls to listen or check. Those in their inner circles can treat others like rubbish and probably with their Blessing. I hope that one day Justice will prevail
avatar
B'John Dalli bhala kap nara li l-PN kien ikollu cans li jnaqqas id-distakk ta' 12%. Imma dan issa jista' biss isir jekk, wara li Gonzi jaqla' tkaxkira nobis, issir elezzjoni ghall-hatra ta' Kap gdid u John Dalli jibda' rivoluzzjoni nterna fi hdan il-partit biex jehilsu mill-hafna sangisugi u nies li huma nkompetenti u opportunisti li hemm bhalissa. Nara wkoll li sa l-elezzjoni ta' 2018 il-PN ikun jista' jaghti sfida qawwija lill-PL jekk ikun irnexxilu jaghmel din il-biddla. U ma niskantax jekk nies utili hafna bhal Franco Debono, Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando u Jesmond Mugliett jergghu jimmilitaw fi hdan il-PN, metq dan isir partit imnaddaf mill-ghanqbut u xamma kbira ta' korruzzjoni li ghandu llum.
avatar
Igor P. Shuvalov
PN apologist will do a big favour to themselves and the readers if they read what John Dalli is reported to have said. Surely they cannot brand Dalli, who is occupying such a high post in the European Union administration, as some irresponsible backbencher.
avatar
Fost hafna affarijiet dalli qal li "parliament is not functioning.... It is an essential institution which, in my opinion, is being disfigured ..... It is harmful for the entire country." Jiddispjacini tafux imma jidher car li minn brussell fejn jghix, is-sur dalli ma jafx tassew x'qed jigri f'malta. Ta' min ifakkru li l-parlament taghna llum hu mmexxi minn nies ta' kalibru bhal gonzipn (ex-speaker), michael frendo (speaker li qabel kien responsabbli mit-tender tal-biljetti tal-karozzi tal-linja), tonio borg (leader of the house li ghandu bhala konsulent il-parker ta' quddiem il-bank centrali), karm mifsud bonnici (qabel ma qalftuh 'l barra shabu stess) ..... u peress li dawn "l-imhuh" kollha mhumiex bizzejjed, issa talbu ghal konsulent iehor fil-forma tal-professur ian refalo !!! X'irridu izjed - mhux team fantastiku u tal-ghageb dan li semmejt jew? what could we ask for more !!! u mela jigi dalli jghidilna li l-parlament taghna hi sfigurat !!! sfigurat sabih - b'dawn il-bravi kollha!!! sinjal li ma jafx x'qed jghid dalli - u naturalment, m'ahnix insemmu l-parlament il-gdid ta' renzo piano .... forsi dalli kien qed jghid ghalih ghax dak veru li mhux "functioning" ghax ghadu qed jinbena ghalkemm gonzipn mohhu biex jinawgurah hu qabel l-elezzjoni ghax jahseb li b'hekk se jirbah eluf u eluf ta' voti .....
avatar
Fost hafna affarijiet dalli qal li "parliament is not functioning.... It is an essential institution which, in my opinion, is being disfigured ..... It is harmful for the entire country." Jiddispjacini tafux imma jidher car li minn brussell fejn jghix, is-sur dalli ma jafx tassew x'qed jigri f'malta. Ta' min ifakkru li l-parlament taghna llum hu mmexxi minn nies ta' kalibru bhal gonzipn (ex-speaker), michael frendo (speaker li qabel kien responsabbli mit-tender tal-biljetti tal-karozzi tal-linja), tonio borg (leader of the house li ghandu bhala konsulent il-parker ta' quddiem il-bank centrali), karm mifsud bonnici (qabel ma qalftuh 'l barra shabu stess) ..... u peress li dawn "l-imhuh" kollha mhumiex bizzejjed, issa talbu ghal konsulent iehor fil-forma tal-professur ian refalo !!! X'irridu izjed - mhux team fantastiku u tal-ghageb dan li semmejt jew? what could we ask for more !!! u mela jigi dalli jghidilna li l-parlament taghna hi sfigurat !!! sfigurat sabih - b'dawn il-bravi kollha!!! sinjal li ma jafx x'qed jghid dalli - u naturalment, m'ahnix insemmu l-parlament il-gdid ta' renzo piano .... forsi dalli kien qed jghid ghalih ghax dak veru li mhux "functioning" ghax ghadu qed jinbena ghalkemm gonzipn mohhu biex jinawgurah hu qabel l-elezzjoni ghax jahseb li b'hekk se jirbah eluf u eluf ta' voti .....
avatar
The respected John Dalli hit the nail on its head when he stated, "He insisted that disloyalty "is when one applauds those who do wrong despite being aware of it," and added that "those who unfailingly praise my successes are not friends."
avatar
Zack Depasquale
This is a European Commissioner and a former PN top Minister that is speaking, not some back bencher. So maybe Dr Franco Debono is right and there sure is trouble in GonziPN Government.
avatar
Minimum Wage Freeze.BOOM gidba ohra nazzjonalista imgidba min ex ministru Nazzjonalist. Prosit John Dalli.