Army men acquitted of involuntary murder of gunner

Soldiers acquitted of involuntary murder of 19-year-old Matthew Psaila in underwater exercise gone wrong.

Gunner Matthew Psaila died during a training exercise at Chadwick Lakes
Gunner Matthew Psaila died during a training exercise at Chadwick Lakes

Two soldiers charged with the involuntary homicide of a 19-year-old gunner, Matthew Psaila, have been acquitted today.

Lt Christian Vella, 30 of Zabbar, and Lance Bombardier Marvic Peregin, 34 of Pembroke, were charged with the involuntary homicide of Psaila, of Ta' Xbiex, who died in an exercise held at Chadwick Lakes on 13 February, 2009.

Psaila died during an incident in which soldiers had to swim through an underwater tunnel, but the defence submitted that the young soldier had never informed his superiors that he could not swim, leading to the accident

The defence quoted experts' reports which said that had Gunner Psaila informed his superiors, the accident could have been avoided.

Experts had also testified that one of the conditions for engagement with the Armed Forces was that applicants must be able to swim. But the accused had nothing to do with recruitment into the AFM, nor could they influence the date for the holding of the exercise.

An expert, John Gera, had testified that the temperature of the water was 8ºC and the water was 2.1 metres deep. It was true that the manner which decided the water's depth on the day of the accident, using a cane, was not correct but as all the soldiers had testified in the compilation, they had been asked if they could swim.

Brigadier Maurice Calleja, as an expert, had testified that this type of military exercise was tough and difficult, and sometimes dangerous.

avatar
I strongly believe this is a fair judgement. These soldiers have endured enormous stress since 2009 on the very fact that they were accused of manslaughter, endured enormous expense in their defence and in reality they could never have predicted that the unfortunate Matthew Psaila did not know how to swim. They were training as soldiers do for the eventuality of protecting our Homeland, and had this been a theatre of war it would have been described as an unfortunate death. Dear God give ethernal rest to Matthew Psaila and the courage of endurance to Vella and Peregrin.