​Teenagers falling down the rabbit hole of TikTok’s ‘weight-loss adviser’

On TikTok, a teenager’s worry about their body can become a rabbit hole of fear, restriction and obsession with food that Dar Kenn Għal Saħħtek staff are untangling offline

Under TikTok videos where teenage girls ask strangers whether they need to lose weight, replies often come from other young people asking the same question. They post their own figures, compare their bodies and offer advice on what somebody else should eat, weigh or change.

The conversation does not end beneath one video. Once a user watches, likes or lingers on content about weight loss or body image, TikTok can begin supplying more of it, gradually turning a single insecurity into a feed built around the same fear.

Last week, the European Commission preliminarily found that TikTok’s ‘For You’ feed can lead users into these harmful “rabbit holes”, repeatedly recommending content about body image, mental health, sadness and isolation, even when it may worsen existing distress.

Anton Grech, a psychiatrist who treats people experiencing eating disorders, said the clinical picture is more complex than social media alone. “Social media is projecting an unrealistic lifestyle and an unrealistic image,” he said. “It is not one reason; it is a group of reasons. One of them is the influence of the media.”

For young people already worried about their appearance, social media does not create every fear. But it can give that fear somewhere to go, feeding it with videos, comments and advice from people who may be struggling with the same question.

An answer from strangers

The search for validation can leave somebody feeling worse, particularly when they are asking people online whether they are fat, thin or attractive enough. Stacy Debono, who works with children at Dar Kenn Għal Saħħtek, a therapy centre in Mtarfa, said people cannot base their value on other people’s opinions.

“Social media and AI can feel easier to approach than a parent, doctor or therapist because they are available at any hour,” Debono said, “although the advice they offer is not necessarily reliable.”

Debono said patients often look to other people for a verdict on how they look. “Popular opinions don’t make them right,” she said. “A thought or a comment, or comments, are not facts.”

The search for validation can leave somebody feeling worse. Debono said the strongest comparison is not always with a celebrity or major influencer. “They get more influenced by their friend than by an influencer,” she said. “It doesn’t mean an influencer doesn’t affect them, but the impact is much more on people they know.”

A young person may see a friend at school, then see the same person online in edited photographs, selected outfits and videos that show only the best parts of their day.

From the left: Dietitian Denise Buttigieg childrens worker Stacy Debono and occupational therapist Elke Vandeputte at Dar Kenn Għal Sahhtek (Photo MaltaToday James Bianchi)
From the left: Dietitian Denise Buttigieg childrens worker Stacy Debono and occupational therapist Elke Vandeputte at Dar Kenn Għal Sahhtek (Photo MaltaToday James Bianchi)

When one video becomes a feed

The European Commission’s preliminary findings focused on how TikTok’s recommender system responds to a user’s behaviour.

The platform uses signals including viewing time, likes and other interactions to decide what to show next. The commission says selecting ‘not interested’ may not change a feed, as watch time can outweigh stated preferences.

The commission found that TikTok feeds users harmful streams of content about mental health and body image and the company failed to adequately assess those risks or take effective steps to reduce them.

Grech said social media was one factor among several that can contribute to eating disorders. It is not possible to point to an individual video, account or influencer and say that it caused somebody to become ill.

More than food

At Dar Kenn, staff see what can happen when worries around food, weight and appearance begin to take over somebody’s daily life.

Eating disorders are often reduced to a question of food—eating too little, avoiding meals or exercising excessively. But staff at the centre say that explanation misses much of what is happening.

“A lot of people think that an eating disorder is fixed by fixing food,” Debono said. “An eating disorder is the tip of the iceberg.” Underneath, she said, there may be anxiety, family difficulties, trauma, attachment issues or a person’s need to control something in their life.

Dietician Denise Buttigieg said young people whose body-image concerns affect eating may start restricting food, avoiding particular foods or whole food groups, or engaging in purging behaviours.

Some avoid foods they believe cause weight gain or skin problems. Others fast, over-exercise, misuse laxatives, or induce vomiting. Social media can repackage these fears as advice. Videos promoting food-group restrictions, calorie tracking, or harder exercise may appear to encourage healthy discipline while reinforcing the restrictive thinking clinicians treat.

Food restriction and excessive exercise without adequate nutrition can lead to malnutrition, Buttigieg said. During adolescence, that can disrupt development and create long-term health risks.

The illness does not always begin with a dramatic change in appearance. It can emerge in somebody who slowly stops eating with their family, avoids going out with friends, becomes frightened of particular foods or spends hours thinking about how their body looks.

A person can still be doing well at school, Debono said, while their concentration is increasingly consumed by food, weight and appearance. They may stop doing things they once enjoyed because their concerns leave little room for anything else.

House rules at Dar Kenn Għal Saħħtek include avoiding comments about food, body image, diets and personal difficulties. (Photo MaltaToday James Bianchi)
House rules at Dar Kenn Għal Saħħtek include avoiding comments about food, body image, diets and personal difficulties. (Photo MaltaToday James Bianchi)

Inside Dar Kenn

Inside the building, Smiles, the golden retriever who lives at Dar Kenn Għal Saħħtek, is a familiar presence in the corridor. A handwritten sign outside the craft room reads: “Small steps lead to big changes.”

Along the corridor, colourful posters carry other messages, including “Always believe in yourself”, while one wall asks children to think about how they feel.

The craft room is where younger patients can draw, write and make things, including messages of encouragement for other children who may come after them. Tables are covered in pens, paper and craft materials, while the walls are filled with work left behind.

Treatment is not simply about telling somebody what they should eat. Buttigieg said she discusses the basics of nutrition in a simplified way and explains the different roles food can have in life: Health, pleasure, celebration and self-expression.

“The approach to feared foods, food restriction and anxiety about weight change is individual, and there is no single intervention that works for every patient,” she said. Therapy can also involve helping patients understand the difference between their perception of their body and reality.

In one exercise, a patient draws the outline of their body as they believe it looks, then staff trace their actual outline in another colour. In another, they estimate how much string is needed to go around their waist; often, Debono said, they cut a much longer piece than necessary.

The point is not to make somebody accept a particular body shape. It is to help them understand the distorted perception that may be driving body checking, anxiety and avoidance.

If a patient has stopped going out for ice cream with friends because eating in public feels overwhelming, treatment can begin with discussing what they would feel comfortable ordering. The aim is to help them return to the parts of life their fears have taken away.

Artwork made by a young person is displayed inside Dar Kenn Għal Saħħtek. (Photo MaltaToday James Bianchi)
Artwork made by a young person is displayed inside Dar Kenn Għal Saħħtek. (Photo MaltaToday James Bianchi)

Diet advice on the phone

Buttigieg said adolescents commonly use calorie- and nutrition-tracking applications, BMI calculators and apps that track movement and energy expenditure.

Older adolescents and adults appear more likely to seek nutrition advice through social media, she said, while younger users can be especially susceptible to comparing their bodies with influencers. “By default, popularity is based on sensationalism rather than accuracy,” Buttigieg said.

Fearmongering and extreme claims travel quickly online. They can reinforce beliefs that certain foods should be feared, or that fasting and other extreme practices are necessary to be healthy.

The marketing of diet, fitness and skincare products to minors can add to that pressure. Buttigieg said misinformation can make taking care of physical health appear expensive and resource-heavy, while also undermining trust in healthcare professionals and public guidelines.

Off-the-shelf diet products can be ineffective at best and dangerous at worst, she warned. Some may carry risks including anxiety, electrolyte disturbance, high blood pressure and irregular heart rhythms, while also interfering with growth and development.

“If you're calling yourself an influencer, you should know that you are going to influence,” Buttigieg said.

People presenting information as fact should make sure it is correct, distinguish personal opinion from professional guidance and recognise the limits of their knowledge, she said.

“If you are not qualified to say what you’re going to say, you either have to ask someone to fact-check you or simply don’t say anything unless you’re perfectly sure it is correct,” she said.

Occupational therapist Elke Vandeputte said the answer is not simply to take social media away. A ban, she said, may only push young people to use another person’s phone or account instead. The work is to help them recognise the editing, preparation and selective images behind what they see online, and understand that a polished feed is not real life.

Vandeputte said young people often do not see the work behind an apparently effortless post—the editing, the filters and the time spent preparing an image to look “perfect”. What appears on a feed, she said, can become a standard against which they measure themselves.

She said responsibility should not sit with influencers alone. Platforms also have a role in preventing harmful material from reaching younger users, while parents and carers need to remain aware of what children are seeing online.

“We influence each other all the time,” Vandeputte said. A person does not need thousands of followers to affect somebody else; an ordinary post about hating an outfit or feeling fat can still influence the people who see it.

Looking beyond the screen

Parents can’t monitor every video or search, but they can spot changes. Buttigieg cited warning signs such as altered eating habits, looser clothes, isolation, avoiding family meals or social events, intense interest in food labels, and increased social-media use.

None of these signs, on their own, confirms that somebody has an eating disorder. But they are reasons to ask questions rather than dismissing the change as a phase. Parents should avoid comments or compliments about body shape, features or eating habits, she said.

For a young person caught in an endless stream of content about weight and appearance, the feed may feel like a place to find answers. The question is, are those answers the right ones.