Why we chose not to publish Adrian Delia’s separation judgment
Like any other politician, if Delia is to be judged, this should be on the basis of his public performance and private matters that truly cast a doubt on his integrity
A politician’s right to privacy is not absolute. Indeed, the Maltese courts have time and again argued that holders of public office, elected officials and persons who exert a public function can and should be held to a different standard than ordinary individuals.
This also means that a politician’s behaviour in their private life can be subject to public scrutiny by the media if that behaviour is criminal, unethical or in contrast with what that politician is preaching publicly.
Nonetheless, the decision to cast a spotlight on a politician’s private behaviour is never straightforward, especially when this involves a very personal matter such as marital separation. It is a decision that has to weigh the public’s right to know what its elected officials are up to and the politician’s right to privacy, which is less onerous than that afforded to ordinary individuals.
Over the past days certain quarters in the information landscape, including One News, chose to publish details from the judgment in Nationalist MP Adrian Delia’s marital separation proceedings. We will not judge their decision to do so. The onus is on them to justify their course of action.
MaltaToday will not be publishing the details of the judgment delivered recently by the Civil Courts. Unlike a criminal complaint or a criminal case, separation proceedings are of a civil nature and thus have to be treated differently. Separation proceedings, especially when the breakup is acrimonious, can be deeply personal and by their very nature involve other family members.
Given Delia’s public role, the question we tried to answer is: Does anything contained in the judgment compromise his public role or cast doubt on his integrity, and thus rendering the matter one of public interest?
We read the voluminous judgment. We read the claims and counterclaims made by the spouses. We internally debated the court’s observations and conclusions. We have weighed those conclusions against Delia’s public role, as an MP, and considered the public’s right to know.
In our considered view nothing in the judgment crosses the threshold that justifies publishing the details of the separation and publicly re-opening the wound for the family.
Our decision has nothing to do with whether we have sympathy for Delia or not. Neither has it anything to do with what others expect us to do. The decision is based solely on our reading of the judgment.
Any behaviour attributed to Delia throughout the proceedings that could potentially be of public interest if read at a superficial level, is contextualised by the judge and in our considered view does not warrant further scrutiny. None of the issues raised surpass the threshold that differentiates between mere curiosity and the people’s right to know.
Delia may be a public person with more responsibilities than ordinary individuals but his separation proceedings are a private matter and should have no impact on his public role or how people view him.
Like any other politician, if Delia is to be judged, this should be on the basis of his public performance and private matters that truly cast a doubt on his integrity.
Let the clowns in
It is pathetic that Labour MP Nigel Vella should claim a breach of privilege because someone called him a clown and ask the Speaker of the House to rule on it. Vella may be new to the House, having been elected for the first time in the last general election but he has been in politics long enough to know that such criticism is par for the course. It’s one thing to feel offended but a totally different thing to ask the Speaker to rule on the matter.
Vella was called a clown by Joseph Farrugia, the former director general of the Malta Employers Association who is now a committee member of the association representing artists. Farrugia was reacting to a series of parliamentary questions that Vella made concerning Farrugia’s public appointments and the resultant remuneration. The PQs were not innocent. They appeared to be part of a wider campaign fomented by Labour apologist and Russophile Neville Gafa in defence of Culture Minister Malcolm Paul Agius Galea, who got hammered by artists over controversial remarks he made.
Farrugia perceived Vella’s PQs and his subsequent comments as an attempt to intimidate him, which is why he called Vella and Gafa clowns. It was a defiant reaction.
The whole incident is really a storm in a teacup but Vella should be aware that in his new role, he is the elected official and so, the one in power. Being able to handle the word ‘clown’ is the least we expect him to do.
-
National
WATCH | Nigel Vella: ‘I was insulted because of my job as an MP’
-
National
Net journalist Chayenne Riolo is the PN's new communications director
-
National
WATCH | Cannabis regulator's outstanding accounts to be published 'really soon,' minister promises
More in News-
Business News
The new face of financial fraud
-
Business News
EY National Tax Conference revisits the history and evolution of taxation in Malta
-
Business News
TradeMalta: Creating lasting value for Malta-based businesses
More in Business-
Other Sports
Erskine Vella appointed Birgu Regatta Club president
-
Other Sports
Mark Marlow elected vice-president of European Federation for Company Sport
-
Football
Birkirkara FC move closer to their first 11-a-side ground
More in Sports-
Music
WATCH | Late Brikkuni guitarist Andrew Schembri’s spirit lives on in band’s latest album
-
Film
Robert Pattinson is Bond, James Bond
-
Music
Filgħodu: Singer-songwriter Philip Vella celebrates love in life’s simplest moments
More in Arts-
Opinions
Malta’s growing debt: Who will pay the price tomorrow?
-
Opinions
If you are unhappy with the ministry you’ve been given, turn it down
-
Opinions
The Clyde, Malcolm episode a case of systemic malaise
More in Comment-
GourmetToday
READ: November editions of Gourmet Today and Architecture & Design magazines available to read online
-
Interviews
In conversation with architect David Felice
-
Restaurants
IBER&CO & CASA PEPA: Two ways to love Spain
More in Magazines