The Clyde, Malcolm episode a case of systemic malaise

Openly blaming others for not heeding his warnings is no redemption from the fact that we have no real solution for the population spike

Finance Minister Clyde Caruana and Culture Minister Malcolm Paul Agius Galea
Finance Minister Clyde Caruana and Culture Minister Malcolm Paul Agius Galea

I think enough has been said about the culture minister. Yet, it is evident that Malcolm Paul Agius Galea is so unaware of how limited he is as culture minister that he cannot quite figure out what to do next. After having undermined his own position with politically insensitive comments and having lost the respect of the Maltese culture scene, he hangs on.

He was also rebuked by his boss, the prime minister, but only when prompted by a MaltaToday journalist. Abela stopped short of taking a decision to remove him and replace him with someone more suitable.

Malcolm, it appears has no clue what culture is about. Worse still, his political acumen is stunted and narrow.

The biggest problem with a politician is when they do not comprehend how stupid they are. Malcolm falls into this category.

Malcolm’s role as minister should be decided not by his electoral successes but by his ability to administer a ministry and ensure the political manifesto of his party is implemented. If he cannot deliver then he is the wrong man for the job and Robert Abela should take the bold step of removing him.

And that is the malaise.

In Maltese politics the decision to bring in line unsuitable politicians is always premised on how bad the situation is with the public when it should all be about standards, ethics, accountability and competence.   

Malcolm fails miserably on competence but politicians like Robert Abela value loyalty more than anything else, it seems.

Malcolm’s hara kiri came hot on the heels of explosive declarations made by Finance Minister Clyde Caruana, who as head of JobsPlus during the Muscat years repeatedly said Malta needed a massive injection of foreign labour to turn the sluggish economy into a tiger economy.

Eight years down the line Caruana reveals that he penned a report in 2018 that spoke of the dangers of the population spike. He reminded us that the report was ignored and shelved. Robert Abela reminded everyone in a statement that as prime minister he had not received the report.

But that is not the point.

The point is that, whereas as a newspaper we love to know about the inner dealings of the Cabinet and government, I have to say it is rather rich for Caruana to cry wolf about the population explosion. Let us face it, he was the chief architect.

Caruana was not only the JobsPlus chief until January 2020, but he was also Robert Abela’s chief of staff when the latter became prime minister. Caruana was then singled out by Abela to become finance minister. And as minister he has proposed and embraced an economic policy that encourages dependence on foreign labour.

The decision to ignore his own report’s contents was his as much as it was of others. Openly blaming others for not heeding his warnings is no redemption from the fact that we have no real solution for the population spike.

Neither does it exculpate his government for not thinking about the repercussions of having thousands of foreigners working here and not taking into consideration the impact on our infrastructural limitation and others stresses such as traffic, educational and health services.

And once again it points to one malaise, the one that has to do with the way the government is acting in terms of political direction and policies. It starts from the prime minister, who needs to outline a clear agenda for his government.

He also needs to get his choir singing from the same hymn book. The problem is choosing the right song. Unfortunately, the chosen song points to populism with no reference to social democratic considerations.

Prime Minister Robert Abela has to appreciate that there needs to be more clarity and cohesion from his ministers and parliamentary secretaries. He needs to appreciate that he heads a Labour Party not a right-wing populist grouping.

And I say it for the umpteenth time, the fact that he gets away with murder, is because the Opposition led by Alex Borg fails to take advantage of the weaknesses and apparent blunders in government.

No matter what is said, Borg is failing to impress and not clear and resolute in his reactions.

It is left to his more astute and eloquent MPs, Adrian Delia and Darren Carabott to cause some damage to the government’s bastion.

We need to have serious political discussions about planning and the labour market. But we cannot have this if we do not have clarity and direction on both sides of the political divide.

Clyde Caruana and Malcolm Paul Agius Galea make interesting topics for discussion at dinner parties, social events and newsroom banter, but their antics are making no sense for either their government or Malta.

We are running out of time in this chaotic Dubai in the middle of the Mediterranean. In the meantime, Malta is burning and no one is noticing.