Additional drainage connections do not automatically aggravate a servitude
Adding a bathroom and kitchenette to an apartment does not, in itself, constitute an unlawful increase in the burden of an existing drainage servitude
Ian Barbara
Adding a bathroom and kitchenette to an apartment does not, in itself, constitute an unlawful increase in the burden of an existing drainage servitude.
This was the ruling delivered by the Civil Court in dismissing the drainage-related claims against the upstairs owners.
The court also held that discovering damage to a drainage pipe after renovation works had been completed did not, in itself, establish that the works had caused the damage. Evidence suggesting that the works might have caused or aggravated the damage, established only a possibility and did not discharge the plaintiffs’ burden of proving causation on a balance of probabilities.
Judge Henri Mizzi, presiding over the First Hall of the Civil Court, delivered judgment on 29 October 2026 in Giovanni Dalli et al. vs Emanuel Baldacchino et al. The court dismissed the claims seeking the removal of the additional drainage connections and compensation for damage allegedly caused by the renovation works.
The dispute concerned two ground-floor properties owned by the Dalli family in Marsaskala and a second-floor apartment belonging to Baldacchino. An existing drainage servitude allowed the drainage pipes serving the upstairs properties to pass through the downstairs property.
The central questions were whether the defendant’s renovations had unlawfully aggravated the existing servitude and whether the works had caused the damage subsequently discovered beneath the plaintiffs’ courtyard.
In 2020, the defendants renovated their apartment, adding a bathroom and kitchenette with the necessary drainage connections. The plaintiffs alleged that the apartment had been divided into two separate residences and that the additional pipes had increased the burden on the existing drainage system.
The defendants denied that any subdivision had taken place. They maintained that the property remained a single apartment, used for residential purposes through room-sharing arrangements, and that the additional facilities did not overload the drainage system.
In July 2021, sewage seepage was reported in an adjoining garage. A test conducted by the Sanitation Department, involving the introduction of dye through the defendants’ apartment, resulted in the dye subsequently appearing in the garage. A contractor then discovered a crack in an old drainage pipe beneath the courtyard, in the branch serving the upstairs apartments, and repaired it at the plaintiffs’ expense.
The plaintiffs attributed the damage to the renovation works and sought compensation, including associated travel expenses. The defendants disputed causation, pointing to the pipe’s age, its condition and possible blockages. They also emphasised that the works had been completed approximately one year before the problem was identified.
The court first examined the scope of the existing drainage rights. The deeds confirmed that the defendants’ apartment already benefited from the servitude. The issue was therefore whether the alterations exceeded the rights granted or imposed an additional burden on the property subject to the servitude.
Applying Article 475 and the related provisions of the Civil Code, while also considering relevant jurisprudence, the court explained that additional drainage connections were not automatically unlawful. Their effect had to be assessed in light of the permitted use, the capacity of the existing system and whether they caused any actual prejudice to the property bearing the servitude.
The evidence did not establish that the apartment had been converted into two separate dwellings or that the additional connections served another property or floor. Although the plaintiffs’ architect identified the new connections, he did not demonstrate that they compromised the capacity of the existing drainage system. Conversely, the defendants’ architect concluded that the system could accommodate the additional facilities, and this technical conclusion was not contradicted by other expert evidence.
The court consequently rejected the allegation that the drainage servitude had been unlawfully aggravated.
On the question of causation, the dye test established that the leaking water originated from the building’s drainage system. However, it did not establish that the defendants had caused the defect.
Although the contractor suggested that movement during the renovation works could have damaged the pipe, he had not witnessed the works and could not confirm that this was what had occurred. Furthermore, there was no evidence establishing the condition of the pipe before the renovation. Ultimately, the court considered the plaintiffs’ explanation less probable than the alternative causes, particularly that the pipe’s age and condition had led to the defect.
The plaintiffs therefore failed to establish liability on a balance of probabilities. The court left undecided whether there might be a separate obligation to contribute towards the repair costs, since the claim before it concerned damages allegedly caused by the defendants’ conduct rather than the sharing of maintenance expenses.
The defendants succeeded in defending the drainage-related claims, although the court separately ordered the removal of six iron supports that had been left across the courtyard.
This judgment illustrates that additional drainage connections do not automatically constitute an unlawful aggravation of an existing servitude, just as a leak discovered after renovation works does not, by itself, establish liability for the resulting damage.
Such claims must be supported by evidence demonstrating both the actual impact of the works on the servitude and a sufficiently established causal link between the works and the alleged damage.
-
National
Demonstrators urge government to withdraw anti-TCN measures
-
National
SDM ends Pulse's 10-year streak in Junior College
-
Court & Police
Accused sent ex-girlfriend 314 messages in two months despite protection order, court hears
More in News-
Business News
A Tuesday supermarket trip could bring €10 cashback for Mastercard cardholders
-
Tech & Gaming
Maltese maritime flag makes appearance in GTA 6
-
Business News
Paolo Catalfamo steps down as LifeStar Insurance chairman
More in Business-
Other Sports
Erskine Vella appointed Birgu Regatta Club president
-
Other Sports
Mark Marlow elected vice-president of European Federation for Company Sport
-
Football
Birkirkara FC move closer to their first 11-a-side ground
More in Sports-
Art
Stuta: Austin Camilleri at St John’s Co-Cathedral, Valletta
-
Theatre & Dance
The Nutcracker brings festive magic to Teatru Manoel this December
-
Music
Jazz Assemblea brings Malta's jazz community together in Valletta
More in Arts-
Opinions
From budget promises to classroom progress
-
Opinions
The predicament of TCNs
-
Opinions
The cost of a two-tier Malta
More in Comment-
GourmetToday
READ: November editions of Gourmet Today and Architecture & Design magazines available to read online
-
Interviews
In conversation with architect David Felice
-
Restaurants
IBER&CO & CASA PEPA: Two ways to love Spain
More in Magazines