The cost of a two-tier Malta
When the conversation at work or at the band club turns to what “they” cost us, we can point out what we stand to lose as well
Much has been said about the budget measures affecting third country nationals. Numerous NGOs and social partners have described them as discriminatory and unjust, focusing on how the measures will impact the targeted people.
On the other hand, the government’s reasoning deserves to be stated fairly. The finance minister has explained it more fully since budget day, insisting the aim is to realign the economy, and that cruelty to foreign workers is not part of it. Since around half of third country nationals change employer every year, he expects employers to absorb the higher permit costs, so that each worker costs more, firms hire fewer, and investment goes into technology and automation instead. Read in this way, the measures are an economic instrument, and their target is the employer.
An economy which grows mainly by adding people cannot keep doing so forever. We accept that the problem is real, and that the mechanism may well work as the minister intends. Our concern is with something which economics does not measure. A measure designed for employers may still be felt by workers, and by the people around them, encouraging a sense of ‘us’ and ‘them’ even if every economic forecast behind it turns out to be correct.
“So what?”, one might ask. Why should we locals and long-term residents (who get to keep free public transport and free childcare, and on top of that get the super bonus) care about this? The question may sound selfish, but we would like to consider it seriously on its own terms.
Discrimination affects everyone
Suppose that we indeed only care about ourselves. A budget which charges others for services that we get for free then looks like a good deal, and many see it that way. However, money and comfort are only part of what we want from life, and probably not the larger part. We also want friends and decent neighbours, and children who grow up into decent adults; and when we are old or ill, we want to be treated as persons by whoever looks after us. Note that none of this can be had alone, since each of these depends on the people around us, including many whom we have not met yet. If we are going to be selfish, then, we should at least be selfish about the things which matter most to us.
Simone de Beauvoir worked through this problem in The Ethics of Ambiguity, written in Paris shortly after the Second World War. Existentialists were often accused of turning individual freedom into a kind of selfishness, and her reply was that this misreads what freedom is. We come to know the world through other people since, in her words, “one can reveal the world only on a basis revealed by other men”. Our plans, too, only mean something if there are others to take them up and carry them on after us. For this reason, she concluded that “to will oneself free is also to will others free”, and she added that this points each of us towards concrete action. On her account, then, selfishness which is followed through to the end turns into concern for others.
A two-tier society weakens social cohesion
Consider first the childcare measure. From 2027, new applicants for free childcare will need to be Maltese, EU citizens or long-term residents, although families already in the scheme keep it. In practice, fewer children of recent arrivals will sit in the same nurseries as Maltese children, at the age when children mix most easily. Note that this is our loss as well as theirs. Our children lose classmates who might later have become friends or colleagues, i.e., some of the very people through whom, in Beauvoir’s terms, the world is revealed to them. A society which keeps a large share of its residents at arm’s length is giving itself a smaller world.
The second cost is to our character. Moral habits are formed in the same way as other habits, by repetition. Each time we accept that the carer who looks after an elderly parent now pays (directly or indirectly) a plethora of new fees so while we get the super bonus, we practise a little indifference. None of us chose these measures. However, living alongside them in silence is also a choice, and Beauvoir was blunt about this: “Any abstention is complicity.”
A few voices suggested donating their super bonus, it is a starting point, we will too, and we will make sure it will be used to offset, just a tiny little, this social injustice.
The third cost is harder to see. The measures sort people by what they cost and what they contribute. As we said at the start, there may be a fair economic case for managing numbers through price. Still, a society which gets used to judging people by their usefulness is unlikely to keep that habit for foreigners only. Sooner or later most of us grow old or fall ill, and then we depend on others not to apply the same yardstick to us.
Our own cause
Beauvoir distrusted charity practised from the outside, by people who stay detached from those they help, and she wrote instead that “the cause of freedom is not that of others more than it is mine”. Read in this light, objecting to these measures is in our own interest as much as in the interest of those directly affected. What is asked of us is small and concrete.
We can ask our MPs how these measures fit the kind of country we want our children to inherit. We can make sure that the newcomers on our street, or at our children’s school, know our names and that we know theirs. And when the conversation at work or at the band club turns to what “they” cost us, we can point out what we stand to lose as well.
-
National
New loading bays irk Birgu residents
-
Court & Police
Suspected fuel smuggler fighting extradition to Spain granted bail
-
National
PL claims to have received leaked amendments to PN statute
More in News-
Tech & Gaming
Maltese maritime flag makes appearance in GTA 6
-
Business News
Paolo Catalfamo steps down as LifeStar Insurance chairman
-
Business News
APS Bank saves over 60,000 working hours and €1 million through automation
More in Business-
Other Sports
Erskine Vella appointed Birgu Regatta Club president
-
Other Sports
Mark Marlow elected vice-president of European Federation for Company Sport
-
Football
Birkirkara FC move closer to their first 11-a-side ground
More in Sports-
Cultural Diary
The art of making things last: a Repair Café in Floriana
-
Music
WATCH | Late Brikkuni guitarist Andrew Schembri’s spirit lives on in band’s latest album
-
Film
Robert Pattinson is Bond, James Bond
More in Arts-
Opinions
Indispensable yesterday, disposable today
-
Editorial
Why we chose not to publish Adrian Delia’s separation judgment
-
Opinions
Malta’s growing debt: Who will pay the price tomorrow?
More in Comment-
GourmetToday
READ: November editions of Gourmet Today and Architecture & Design magazines available to read online
-
Interviews
In conversation with architect David Felice
-
Restaurants
IBER&CO & CASA PEPA: Two ways to love Spain
More in Magazines