Indispensable yesterday, disposable today

Socialism is not something one wears around one’s neck. It is something one demonstrates in taking the side of the least powerful, particularly those who have no vote, no powerful lobby and little means of defending themselves

File photo
File photo

There was something viscerally reprehensible about the budget speech on 26 October. The spectacle of a man sporting a red tie, perhaps as a token of his professed “socialist” convictions, announcing measures that would place additional burdens on some of the most vulnerable workers in our society—third country nationals, conveniently reduced to the bureaucratic acronym TCNs.

Let us be clear about what has happened. For years, Malta has pursued an economic model increasingly dependent on importing labour to sustain growth. More workers, more economic activity, more GDP. And, of course, more opportunities for the government to celebrate its economic achievements and sustain that all-important feel-good factor. But economic growth is not necessarily economic progress.

An economy that grows principally by increasing the number of people working, rather than by increasing productivity, is an economy whose apparent success can conceal serious structural weaknesses. And who encouraged this model? Who presided over its expansion? Who celebrated its results? Who had the responsibility to anticipate its consequences for housing, infrastructure, healthcare, education and the bargaining power of workers? The government. Not the delivery driver. Not the hotel cleaner. Not the construction worker. Not the carer looking after our elderly. Yet, now that the consequences of this model have become increasingly difficult to ignore, it is precisely these workers who are being asked to shoulder additional burdens.

Let me be absolutely clear about something; public transport is not a luxury and neither is childcare. The ability to get to work, to raise a family with a modicum of dignity is not a privilege to be bestowed or withdrawn according to one’s nationality.

Consider that the median, monthly employment income is €1,517 before deductions, according to Central Bank of Malta figures for 2024. At that level of income, an additional €33 a month for public transport is no trivial inconvenience. Add to this the possible loss of childcare support, additional permit-related costs and the already considerable burden of housing, food and other necessities. For workers and families already struggling to make ends meet, these measures risk pushing them closer to poverty, or driving them deeper into it.

And what, precisely, is the economic logic behind charging these workers for public transport? Did it ever occur to Clyde Caruana that this measure might prove counterproductive?

Consider the arithmetic. With a difference of just €50 a month between the proposed public transport charge and the monthly driving-licence charge, private transport could become a more attractive alternative for workers obliged to travel at irregular hours, move between different workplaces or take on additional jobs simply to survive. Admittedly, owning and operating a vehicle involves additional costs. But for workers whose livelihoods depend on mobility and flexibility, the calculation is not simply about the price of a bus ticket. It is about time, accessibility and the ability to earn a living.

And the consequences? Potentially fewer passengers on public transport, more vehicles clogging already congested roads, more air pollution and yet greater pressure on the very infrastructure the government claims to be protecting. What an extraordinary contradiction! A government that laments the pressures of population growth introduces a measure that could discourage the use of public transport and aggravate those very pressures. Where is the coherence? Where is the planning? Where is the assessment of the social and economic consequences? Or has the government become so preoccupied with maintaining its precious feel-good factor that the consequences of its decisions have become a secondary consideration?

Every measure has consequences

A budget is not merely an exercise in extracting revenue from one section of society to distribute it to another in pursuit of electoral approval. Nor is it simply an exercise in balancing figures. It is an expression of political priorities, economic choices and, ultimately, moral values.

Every measure has consequences. And those consequences must be examined before the burden is imposed, not discovered afterwards by the people least able to bear it. That is what responsible government demands. Not the cynical arithmetic of political convenience, but the courage to govern according to principles, even when those principles carry an electoral cost.

I see another extraordinary moral contradiction. For years, these people were indispensable. We needed them to build our apartments, staff our hotels, serve our restaurants, deliver our food, clean our streets and care for our elderly. Their labour contributed to the economic expansion from which businesses profited and successive governments derived political capital. They were invited in, when the economy needed them. Now, apparently, they are a problem. And what makes them such a convenient target? One politically significant characteristic is that they cannot vote in Malta’s national elections. They contribute to the economy. They pay taxes. They work. But they cannot hold the government accountable at the ballot box. This raises a deeply troubling question. Is the government allocating the costs of its economic policies according to responsibility and capacity to pay, or according to the political vulnerability of those expected to bear them?

An alternative

There is an alternative. If the expansion of Malta’s workforce has generated additional infrastructure costs, employers who benefited from that expansion could be required to contribute according to their size and profitability. Small businesses should not necessarily be treated in the same way as large, highly profitable enterprises. But there must be one absolute condition—not a single cent of these contributions should be recovered from workers through wage deductions, recruitment charges, reduced benefits or any other disguised mechanism. That protection must be written into law, enforced and backed by meaningful penalties. Those who benefited from the economic model must share responsibility for its consequences. Those who designed and promoted it must answer for their decisions. And those who came here to work must not become its convenient scapegoats.

There is something particularly disturbing about this spectacle coming from a party that still calls itself Labour. A party whose supporters proudly sing “sew ħilitna kemm saħħitna b’ħila nagħtu għall-fqajrin”—professing solidarity with those who have the least. Where is that solidarity now? What meaning does the word Labour retain if the rights and dignity of workers become negotiable according to their nationality? What remains of socialism when the politically powerless are expected to bear costs generated by decisions over which they had no control?

Today TCNs, tomorrow who?

And there is a still more disturbing question. If political convenience becomes the principle by which a government determines who should pay for its mistakes, who will be next? Today it is the TCNs. Tomorrow it could be pensioners, young workers, small businesses or any other group whose interests can be sacrificed without unacceptable electoral consequences. That is the danger of governing by expediency rather than principle. Once the political vulnerability of a group becomes a consideration in allocating public burdens, no group can be entirely confident that it will not eventually find itself in the same position.

Public policy is not supposed to be an exercise in identifying those least able to resist. It is supposed to be an exercise in justice, evidence, accountability and long-term responsibility. Workers cannot be indispensable when their labour generates economic growth and disposable when their presence becomes politically inconvenient.

Perhaps the next time the finance minister delivers a budget of this kind, he should reconsider the colour of his tie. Red may be the colour of the socialist principles supposedly professed by his party, but when political expediency and clinging to the seat of power take precedence over solidarity and the more vulnerable are made to pay for government policy, perhaps a red-brown tie would be a more fitting reflection of the politics of the narrator.

Socialism is not something one wears around one’s neck. It is something one demonstrates in taking the side of the least powerful, particularly those who have no vote, no powerful lobby and little means of defending themselves.

This article can also be found on nebuchadnezzartheneb.substack.com