Update 2 | Ministers deny en masse Muscat allegation

Tit-for-tat allegations over Toni Abela recording.

Government ministers have accused Labour leader Joseph Muscat of creating a diversion after claiming early this morning that a minister had used his influence to release a person from police custody.

"Muscat is trying to divert attention from the scandal that his deputy leader for party affairs Toni Abela is embroiled in... what Abela did shows that the Opposition views the police corps as a political instrument."

In a statement, the government ministers and parliamentary secretaries all denied Muscat's allegation, which they said he had failed to substantiate.

Labour's proposals for the local sporting sector at the Bidnija shooting range today were expectedly overshadowed by pricklier matters than incentives for athletes: Muscat found himself defending his deputy leader for party affairs again, insisting that Toni Abela's intervention with a police officer in 2010 was intending at reining in a civil matter out of police hands.

But in turn, Muscat alleged that a government minister had used his influence to obtain the release of a man in a police lock-up: when asked whether he considered the Abela case was a grave matter, Muscat said, "What if I tell you there was a minister who called for the release of a person from the police lock-up?"

At this point, when journalists asked Muscat to explain the allegation, the Labour leader replied: "You are journalists... investigate."

Muscat defended his position not to release any more comments on his allegation that a minister used his influence to release a person from the police lock-up later throughout the day, during a visit to the Eurosport stores in Birkirkara [VIDEO].

Muscat has been busy fending off questions on a secret recording in which Toni Abela is heard claiming he intervened with the police not to press charges against Richard Vella, formerly a barman at the PL's club in Attard, who has been suspended from the party since 2010.

Vella, charged with starting a fight with Labour local councillor John Bonnici in 2010, produced the recording in court last week to say that Abela had told the police not to press charges against him.

But Abela says he had intervened with the police at the Birkirkara police station because Vella had reported the councillor after his bar's locks had been changed. Abela insists he wrested the case away from the police because this was a civil, not a criminal matter.

"Abela is legally responsible for these party clubs, and he has said that the matter was not of a criminal nature, but a civil case between two individuals," Muscat said today.

Asked whether he deemed the case was now closed, Muscat said he had nothing to add about the content of the recordings he had heard.

Pointed questions to Muscat from the press asked the Labour leader whether he was on Abela's side: "I'm on justice's side," Muscat replied.

Muscat was also quizzed on whether Judge Lino Farrugia Sacco, who faces an impeachment motion filed by the Prime Minister, should step down from his post as president of the Malta Olympic Committee - over an ethics investigation into the sale of tickets for the Sochi winter games - Muscat said that the judge should "make way" and resign.

Farrugia Sacco's son David is running for parliament on the Labour ticket.

Turning to the Enemalta oil scandal, Muscat drove home the point that emails published in The Times and MaltaToday had confirmed that transport minister Austin Gatt had met oil trader George Farrugia, the Trafigura agent who has been granted a presidential pardon to give evidence on allegations of kickbacks for Enemalta fuel procurement.

Muscat was also asked why he 'laughed' during Wednesday's debate at the University of Malta when he saw Lawrence Gonzi being booed by students present.

"My reaction was no different to that of Gonzi five years ago," Muscat said, generating applause from supporters present at the press conference.

Muscat's proposals at the Bidgnija shooting range commit Labour to four main projects: The development of an indoor swimming pool, the upgrading of Tal-Qroqq's sporting facilities, a national shooting range and the completion of a motor sports track.

avatar
Ministers deny en masse the news that one of them had used his influence to release a person from police custody . Even when the oil scandal came to light they all denied the whole thing . But look what came up . Emails that mentioned the involvment of Minister Austin Gatt . Meetings that were denied at first but when more emails were published later , proved that the denials were a big lie . This could be another lie . They will keep denying untill more evidence brings more light on this issue .
avatar
REPLY TO FENEA, May be Joseph has just found out or the policemen involved have recently informed the PL as they could not bear PN double standards. Journalist do your work!
avatar
The first journalist to discover the errant minister will be given a prize of 1000 euros; PLjournalists and PN journalists with Labour relatives need not apply.
avatar
fenea you seem to be losing it like gonzi. Like desperate men you are both resorting to puerile speech or writing. No matter how much you try because like the maltese saying goes "Hanqa ta' hmar qatt ma telghet is-sema". By the way all will be revealed to those who wait.
avatar
JUST YOU WAIT PROF HIGGINS JUST YOU WAIT. IF JOSEPH MUSCAT MENTIONED THIS ALLEGATION YOU CAN BET YOUR BOTTOM DOLLAR THAT HE HAS EVERYTHING UP HIS SLEEVE. THE MINISTERS HAVE ALL DENIED EN MASSE THE ALLEGATION, THE JOURNALISTS HAVE BEEN GIVEN A CLUE AND AT THE RIGHT MOMENT - CLEARLY NOT WHEN THE PN WANTS TO - HE WILL REVEAL ALL. DO YOU THINK THAT A MINISTER WILL PHONE AN ORDINARY POLICE OFFICER TO RELEASE A PERSON FROM THE LOCK UP? FENEA YOU MUST REALLY BE NAIVE. WHO HAS THE POWER TO DECIDE ON SUCH MATTERS?
avatar
What did you expect the Ministers to say? Nobody is willing to carry the piss bucket now.
avatar
At this point, when journalists asked Muscat to explain the allegation, the Labour leader replied: "You are journalists... investigate....MR MUSCAT YOU SHOULD HAVE REPORTED THIS CASE TO THE POLICE COMMISSIONER. HE HAS THE RIGHT TO INVESTIGATE NOT THE JOURNALISTS. ANGLU WAS RIGHT TELLING YOU THAT HE LOST TRUST IN YOU.
avatar
Skond il-gurnalisti ta GonziPN l-affari tal-kantnazz tal-Labour hu importanissimu u ta gravita nazzjonali: imma l-akbar sakndlu fl-istorja Maltija nahbuh! L-istess qed jaghmel l-PBS! F'pajjiz Ewropew dan mhux accetabli u se jibqa jitfa lil Malta lura fejn bil-fatti qed jehodha is-sistema u ix-xandir sfaccat ta GonziPN!
avatar
Don't these Ministers have any shame? Creating a mountain out of a mole hill? What is the Toni Abela "scoop" then if not a sham!
avatar
No affidavits?
avatar
I cannot understand how an argument between two people from the PL camp in which the deputy leader took the role to solve in a civil way and out of the police hands so that it will not go to court be so inflated and pretend to cover the sorry performance of most ministers. Now that a more grevious case pops up they are all together singing Not Me. And the song goes 'we all fall down'.
avatar
GonziPN strategists must think that the people of Malta and Gozo are all idiots. Isn't it obvious who is trying to create a diversion? Everbody knows that the biggest scandal ever has come to light and the guys and gals at Pieta' are doing their utmost to divert their attention onto trivial matters. Please stop insulting our intelligence, will you?
avatar
It is a shame the the attention was diverted from the best ever sporting proposal for A NATIONAL SHOOTING COMPLEX that will attract thousands of sports shooters to Malta. We have been promised this project for the last 12 years. Hopefully a new goverment will materialize this project for the benefit of Sports tourism.
avatar
Whenever Joseph claimed knowledge about some issue, his claims always proved to be correct. Not the same can be said of GonziPN. This fact is proved by the higher trust that the Maltese in general have in Joseph as opposed to Lawrence. Ministers Gatt, Fenech, Crisina & Pullicino were all embroiled in some blunder or other. Why PN acolytes seem to be surprised by Joseph's claims is mind boggling.
avatar
Din niddedikaha lill-Dr Toni Abela, ghal hidmietu favur is-sewwa. Erhilu l-mewg ha jhabbat. Fl-ahhar Alla jirbah u mhux ix-xjaten. MALTA GHAD ITQUM Bhal xitla minghajr ilma Din Malta qed titbiel Tghawwig u korruzzjoni Tas-sewwa l-ebda hjiel. Qed tghix bil-qtar tat-tama Li jfegg jum il-helsien…. Issehh ir-rieda t’Alla…. Il-qerq jitnezza gharwien.
avatar
@ Zoltan So are you saying that the students who booed did a good thing or not? What counts is that we all know that the majority of University Students still support PN.
avatar
this scandal has showed very clearly that the Police Corps should be under the direct responsibility of the President. Why is the Commissioner of Police and the A.G. dragging their feet to take the 4 people mentioned in this scandal to court? When is George Farrugia going to give evidence in Court? After the election? Justice should not only be done, but appears to be done.
avatar
Desperately trying to divert attention from the worst corruption this island has ever seen. Shame on you PN media. It makes absolutely no difference to me what Toni Abela said to the officer on duty, but the fact that somebody has been benefiting from massive commissions on state-imported fuel oils, does. The media need to get their priorities right.
avatar
Shame on the giornalists that tried to divert the attention from one of the most ambitios project that would attract thousands of International shooters to Malta.
avatar
It's astonishing how sensitive the PN is becoming at being beaten at its own game. In 2008, Dr. Sant was shouted down, jeered and humiliated at the University by a rent-a-crowd that included Daphne and her sister (definitely not students!) amongst others. When Dr. George Vella commented on the base and ignorant nature of many of the taunts that were surely not worthy of the University, he was called a tyrant! Well, in 2013, the PL has shown itself to be on the ball and better organised than the PN. Perhaps the PN should look at Simon and the rest of the party campaign team and structure if it wants culprits to blame for its sorry performance thus far!