Tonio Fenech accuses Labour financial administrator of being behind oil scandal

Finance Minister claims fiduciary company that oil trader George Farrugia used as a front assumes full responsibility for any illegal activity.

Finance Minister Tonio Fenech accused Labour's financial administration of involvement in the oil scandal.
Finance Minister Tonio Fenech accused Labour's financial administration of involvement in the oil scandal.

The Nationalist Party has accused one of the director-shareholders of a fiduciary services company, that oil trader George Farrugia used to shield his ownership of Aikon Ltd, of "being behind the oil scandal" that has engulfed state utility Enemalta.

Fenech accused Joe Cordina (pictured, right), the financial administrator of the Labour Party, of responsibility in any alleged illegal activity Aikon was involved in, because Intershore Fiduciary Services was solely responsible for the firm before 2011.

Cordina is also a Labour candidate on the Gozo (13th) district.

But the minister omitted to name that another director-shareholder of Intershore was former Nationalist candidate Martin Fenech, who is also a paid-up member of the same party.

Fenech claimed that as the person "most closely linked to a political party", Cordina was "behind the oil scandal", although he stopped short of pinpointing exactly what wrongdoing Cordina was alleged to have done.

Fenech is saying that Intershore must be held responsible as the beneficial owner of Aikon: the latter company was the trading front for Farrugia before 2011, when he was sued by his own brothers for millions in oil revenues he siphoned away from family business Powerplan, into Aikon. Powerplan was then the representative for Total and Trafigura before they accepted to be represented by Farrugia's company Aikon.

"I have submitted all financial documentation pertaining to the ownership of Aikon to the Commissioner of Police," Fenech said, alleging that all payments from Trafigura into a New York bank account to Aikon, went ultimately to Intershore.

Fenech insisted that by virtue of his ownership of Intershore, Cordina was responsible for the activities of Aikon before the company was officially transferred to George Farrugia in January 2011.

Farrugia turned State's evidence after he was granted a pardon in return for evidence on kickbacks Trafigura paid a former Enemalta consultant Frank Sammut in 2004. Four businessmen have been charged in connection with the oil scandal.

Fenech claimed that Intershore was the "the ultimate beneficiary" of Aikon before 2011, when any alleged illegal activity took place. "This company was taking ultimate responsibility for this company's activities," Fenech said.

But when it was pointed out that Intershore's other shareholder was Martin Fenech, a former PN candidate in three elections, Fenech appeared unable to answer. Instead, PN secretary-general Paul Borg Olivier replied that "had Fenech been a candidate, we would take the steps necessary."

It transpires that Fenech is still a paid-up member of the PN. "All I can say is what we would do were he still a candidate," Borg Olivier said. "Martin Fenech should answer himself."

Finance Minister Tonio Fenech appeared to open himself up to some very pointed questions from the press, few of which were given a direct reply:

-       When asked whether Martin Fenech himself was guilty of any corruption, the minister reiterated that Intershore served as Aikon's front, and was legally responsible for the activities of Aikon at the time the kickbacks were paid;

-       He did not answer directly a question as to whether Intershore Fiduciary Services had involved itself in illegal activity, limiting himself to saying that he had submitted all documentation of Aikon's previous ownership had been forwarded to the Commissioner of Police.

-       It was pointed out to him that Lawrence Gonzi's own son David, had also been a company secretary of a holding company that received €15 million in laundered cash from the scandal-ridden Maugeri Foundation. But Fenech said he was "not updated on the story and could not comment on it" when asked whether Gonzi, by the same yardstick, was responsible for the company's wrongdoing.

-       He was asked about Aikon's own auditor, Ray Stafrace, who is today procurement officer of transport regulator Transport Malta, but he had no information about this connection.

Fenech also defended a decision to take a tax fraud investigation commenced by the Malta Security Services, which was passed on to the finance ministry, into the hands of the Tax Compliance Unit.

"If the MSS believed this was a criminal investigation it would have been passed on to the economic crimes unit, but in this case it was felt it could be passed on to the TCU - showing that the institutions this government created to fight tax evasion and other acts of corruption, are working," Fenech said.

Fenech also said that if there was any information on gifts allegedly given to Enemalta officials by George Farrugia, the Commissioner of Police should investigate the allegations.

The press conference was brought to an end despite the protestations of two journalists who had not yet asked their questions to Tonio Fenech.

avatar
One would consider it ONE HECK OF A COMPLETE SHAME that it had to be Malta's own Nationalist Party appointed Minister of Finance to drag down the whole of Malta's thriving Financial Services sector into questionable disrepute for purely political, self preservation purposes. I suppose no other Cabinet member wanted to front this questionable, dastardly practice and action. One could see it in FZD's face and body language. I would think that FZD was feeling awful at that press conference. Had there been sufficient reason for Intershore to smell any criminal activity by its client and/or that client's ultimate beneficiary shareholders, AND not report it then yes, the PN's actions would have been justifiable. But, just because one of Intershore's Directors/Shareholders happens to occupy, as well, an Administrative position at the PL, does not give license to Tonio Fenech or any one else of taking the course of action chosen so desperately. If the Minister wanted to act professionally, correctly, and in Malta's best overall interests, he would have given his publicly procured documents to the Police (I am sure these would have been no news to the Police), and asked them to take cognisance of them in their investigations. BUT THAT WAS NOT THE REAL REASON FOR THIS CLOWNING!! There was absolutely no reason for Tonio Fenech to drag Intershore Fiduciary Services Ltd into the OIL SCANDAL MESS, that was perpetrated solely under the PN's watch, and for which they were administratively and politically responsible!!! I expect the organisation responsible for the well being of the FINANCIAL SERVICES sector, and their many, many members to raise their voice in a very strong protest at the blatantly invalid assertion placed at the door on one of their members.
avatar
Fenech said he was not updated on the David Gonzi story. Fair enough. But how come he is updated on the Aikon story? This is very relevant as so far no news has come out that Joe Cordina or any of the two other have been questioned by the police. And how does he know that their company acted as a front for the oil scandal? Is he privy to information which not even the police are privy to? As this financial company is regulated by MFSA which falls under the remit of Tonio Fenech has he received information of wrong doing from this Authority? Tonio Fenech still receives his salary as a Minister and therefore is still responsible to the public that pays his salary. It is not paid by the PN. And the public should be concerned when a Minister makes statements like this but does not lay the cards on the table for the public to be able to judge for themselves. It is not in the interest of the Minister to do so. Many people are claiming that the Minister did this in order to pre-empt the leak of information tying him into the scandal and to deflect attention. And in this confused state of things who can blame people for thinking in this way given that this Minister has already been implicated in other alleged scandals. If the Minister does not want to put all the cards on the table it becomes the responsibility of the PM to do so as he is Head of his ministerial team. Silence is not an option anymore.
avatar
Right from the start of Tonio Fenech's public life he came across as an arrogant pompous braggard. His strengths were (i) a hunger for success, (ii) a burning desire to overcome and (iii) an lack of political ethics. All along, that was nothing more than perception, a gut feeling. During this election campaign, his behaviour indicates correct my gut feelings about him. What’s becoming very surprising is his growing panic, resulting in an abrasive and offensive attitude towards his Labour counterparts and collegues. His fits of anger, on live TV, are raising suspicions in people's minds: what's wrong with the man? What’s wrong with doing time to recuperate and revive? Isn’t that what parliamentary democracy is all about? Labour lost went into opposition and built their organization into shape. Why can't Tonio Fenech and the rest of the GonżiPN accept the possibility, or the probability that they may need to build up their party all over again. Are we to conclude they believe in a monopoly right over people’s lives? Isn't change and evolution what parliamentary democracy is all about? Winning or losing an election means nothing in the life of a nation or a parliament. Majority or minority, political parties have an important role to play in parliament. We all got a role to play. Why Can't GonżiPN accept that possibility?
avatar
Right from the start of Tonio Fenech's public life he came across as an arrogant pompous braggard. His strengths were (i) a hunger for success, (ii) a burning desire to overcome and (iii) an lack of political ethics. All along, that was nothing more than perception, a gut feeling. During this election campaign, his behaviour indicates correct my gut feelings about him. What’s becoming very surprising is his growing panic, resulting in an abrasive and offensive attitude towards his Labour counterparts and collegues. His fits of anger, on live TV, are raising suspicions in people's minds: what's wrong with the man? What’s wrong with doing time to recuperate and revive? Isn’t that what parliamentary democracy is all about? Labour lost went into opposition and built their organization into shape. Why can't Tonio Fenech and the rest of the GonżiPN accept the possibility, or the probability that they may need to build up their party all over again. Are we to conclude they believe in a monopoly right over people’s lives? Isn't change and evolution what parliamentary democracy is all about? Winning or losing an election means nothing in the life of a nation or a parliament. Majority or minority, political parties have an important role to play in parliament. We all got a role to play. Why Can't GonżiPN accept that possibility?
avatar
Mr Cordina resignation to be able to clear his name is by no means acceptace or acknowledgement of the allegations made..... Remember when Minister Chris Said resigned to be able to clear his name?? His resignation was not as part of admittance that he had done something wrong!! So is the case for Mr Cordina. Or is this another issue of two weights and two measures which the Gonzipn specialises in???
avatar
Dalghodu Dr. Martin Fenech spjega b'mod mill-aktar car kif kemm hu u l-kollegi tieghu, Joe Cordina u Charles Scerri QATT ma kellhom xi hjiel li GEorge Farrugia kien qed jaghmel xi haga illegali. Meta kellhom hjiel ta' dan, meta hut George Farrugia ikkontattjaw il-kumpanija ta' Dr. Martin Fenach u shabu rigward problemi ta' flus li kellhom ma huho, huma irrizenjaw mill-kumpanija Fiducjarja u qatghu kull kuntatt mas-Sur George Farrugia ! Il-Body Language ta' Tonio Fenech mhu qed jikkonvinci xejn !
avatar
From what everybody can see is that under PN administration there was and probable still is an easy system where all top selected businessmen find it smooth enough to fill their pockets to the detriment of us citizens sracping a living
avatar
Zack Depasquale
@Fenea Ghax tidher li taf iktar minn haddiehor. Tista tghidli x ghamlu hazin Martin Fenech, Charles Scerri u Joe Cordina? Taf li segretarju ta'Kumpanija huwa effetivament l-amministratur ta'Kumpanija u David Gonzi kien segretarju ta'kumpanija u mhux bicca skrivan kif ippruvajt tpoggiha int? Nahseb l-iktar wiehed qrib Partit implikat f'din l-istorja huwa l-istess Ministru Tonio Fenech. L-istess Ministru li ma kellux diffikulta biex jiehu vjagg b'xejn biex imur jara loghba football, l-anqas kellu problema ma jhalassx il-bolla tal-impjegati tieghu, biex ma nsemmux il-kwistjoni tar-referbushment tad-dar tieghu kif ukoll l-assistent li kien qal li rcieva flus ghal kampanja elettorali tal-istess Ministru. Hemm min jiehu flus kontanti u hemm min jiehu rigali. Nixtieqek tghidilna minn fejn gejjin il-flus tal-Kampanja Eletorali tal-Partit Laburista la qisek taf, zgur mhux gejja minn JS List kif ghandu GonziPN? Nuqqas ta rispopsti ghal dan li staqsejtek min naha tieghek Fenea huwa sinjal li bhal Partit ta'GonziPN int tinsab f'paniku tirrepeti dak li jghidlek l-Oligarkija li lesta li thammeg nies min barra l-politika, Dr Martin Fenech u Charles Scerri huma tnejn min-nies li illum huma barra mill-politika, basta l-istess Oligarkija tibqa terda minn fuq dahar it-taxxi taghna.
avatar
Maureen Attard
Ħawwaddni ħa nifmek.... X'taħwid hawn madoffi.... Lil min irridu navdaw biex imexxi din il-qoxra ta' gzira wkoll.... Kemm hu sabiħ dak is-siġġu. Għalxejn jiġġieldu għalih. Ara veru kollha pezza waħda ta, ħokkli dari, ħa nħokk tiegħek... X'hemm hemm fuq f'dak il-parlament u jew f'kull poter ieħor. Ħallas it-taxxi ħaddiem, mur ċapcpilhom u aqbeż quddiemhom meta jkunu fil-għoli jgħatu l-messaġġi minn fuq il-palk f'xi pjazza. Boloh, xejn iżjed, boloh min jiġġieled għalihom. Nivvota? Ma nafx, oqbra mbajda u xejn iżjed.
avatar
PLEASE ALL NOTE THAT THE INFORMATION GIVEN BY TONIO FENECH IS PUBLIC INFORMATION ON THE WEBSITE OF THE REGISTRAR OF COMPANIES AND IF THE POLICE HAD ANY SUSPICION THEY WOULD HAVE CALLED THE THREE DIRECTORS FOR A STATEMENT..AS FAR AS WE ARE AWARE THIS HAS NEVER BEEN DONE.. FIDUCIARY SERVICES ARE WHAT THEY ARE THEY ARE USED AND ABUSED TO DISGUISE IDENTITY AND UNFORUNTETELY THIS TIME THEY HAVE BEEN ABUSED.
avatar
@Fenea: Saviour ma jaghmilx bhal Tonio Fenech - jitfa t-tajn sabiex jaghtti xturu u ta' shabu. Saviour l-ewwel jinvestiga u mhux ihammeg. Saviour kristjan u mhux bhal oqbra imbajda li jaslu ghal kollox sabiex ihammgu ismijiet ta' nies, inkluz ex kandidat Nazzjonalista Dr Martin Fenech, basta jibqu f' wicc l-ilma. Izda l-gudizzju jasal dalwaqt.
avatar
ILKOM TIPPUNTAW SUBAJKOM LEJN GONZI GATT U FENECH IMMA S'ISSA MA IRNEXXILKOMX IGGIBU PROVA WAHDA LI HUMA IMPLIKATI FIL KAZ. L-EWWEL POLITIKU IMPLIKAT HUWA JOE CORDINA KANDIDAT F'ISEM IL PL U AKTAR IMPORTANTI MIN HEKK AMMINISTRATUR FINANZJARJU TAL PARTIT LABURISTA. X'MA JKOLLOHOMX FLUS TAL LABOUR. ANGLU KELLEK RAGUN TQARRAS WICCEK U JEKK TAGHMEL 1+1 TKUN TAF GHALIEX WARRBEK IL LEADER.
avatar
I think MLP believes we must live in cukoo-land not to get this. So, facts: (1) The Labour treasurer handles its cash, (2) The same man is a director of the company which receives illegal commissions from Trafigura, (3) MUSCAT/MLP say they never knew this. Is it so hard to make the link here !? I mean geez...
avatar
Oil scandal: Labour says I'm In.
avatar
Disgustingly biased reporting as usual. No wonder the site is red and plastered with Malta Taghna llkoll ads. Let's see how much more "positive" Muscat gets...
avatar
SAVIOUR DIN QABZITLEK JEW KONT TAF DWARA U HALLEJTA BARRA GHAX JOE CORDINA HUWA LABURIST. MALTA TAGHNA LKOLL.
avatar
When you point a finger at others the other four are pointing at yourself Tonio.
avatar
MIRIAM QED TIPPROVA TIZVIJA LIL QARREJJA MIL KONTENUT TAL ISTORJA. KOLLOX IRID U SE JINKIXEF ISSA. IZ ZEJT BEDA TIELA F'WICC L-ILMA.
avatar
- It was pointed out to him that Lawrence Gonzi's own son David, had also been a company secretary of a holding company that received €15 million in laundered cash from the scandal-ridden Maugeri Foundation. But Fenech said he was "not updated on the story and could not comment on it" when asked whether Gonzi, by the same yardstick, was responsible for the company's wrongdoing......SEGRETARJU TA KUMPANIJA HUWA SEMPLICI IMPJEGAT. DIRETTUR HUWA DAK LI JMEXXI U RESPONSABBLI TAL KUMPANIJA.
avatar
Dr Martin Fenech is Tonio Fenech's first cousin! Family and friends.
avatar
ma nibdewx inqarqu bil qarrejja miriam please. fenech semma lit tlett persuni involuti u bla dubju l-aktar wiehed implikat fil politika huwa joe cordina - kandidat ghal elezzjoni u AMMINISTRATUR FINANZJARJU TAL PL. DALWAQ INSIRU NAFU MIN FEJN GEJJIN IL FLUS GHAL KAMPANJA ELETTORALI TAL PL.
avatar
Joe Cordina was not nominated on Intershore by PL but he was there on his personnal capacity. On the other hand Tancred Tabone, Austin Gatt's cousin, was niminated by Austin Gatt with the blessing of both you and Dr Gonzi. So what is your point Mr Tonio Fenech? PL could not at anytime check what a member of the party be doing 24/7 in a private capacity but a government nominated official can be and that is the whole problem.Pointing your finger Tonio you will notice 3 pointing at you and you are no angle.
avatar
what goes round comes round ...... politicians are like nappies they should be changed often and for the same reason some are just more full of it than others
avatar
what goes round comes round ...... politicians are like nappies they should be changed often and for the same reason some are just more full of it than others