How new local plans risk reopening Pandora’s box

A review of Malta’s local plans risks reopening the battle over development boundaries, landowners’ expectations and the future of undeveloped land, while leaving residents struggling to keep pace with another overhaul of planning rules where the devil can always be found in the detail

File Photo
File Photo

Prime Minister Robert Abela’s renewed commitment to revise Malta’s local plans reopens a contentious debate over development rights, environmental protection and residents’ quality of life.

Approved in 2006, the plans remain the foundation of Malta’s planning framework, despite subsequent policies and amendments that have altered how they operate. They have facilitated extensive development, including the erosion of village cores, but have also provided safeguards invoked by the courts to block damaging decisions by the Planning Authority.

Labour’s previous attempt at a comprehensive revision, launched in 2013, was eventually shelved after the government was inundated by demands from developers. Will another review correct the shortcomings of the existing framework or open the door to further development?

The issue is not simply whether the plans should be updated, but whose interests the revision will serve. Will government be prepared to reduce development potential, including on land brought into development zones in 2006, or will it mainly accommodate demands from landowners? There is also a question of whether change is better pursued through targeted amendments, such as the proposed extension of Pietà’s urban conservation area, or through a sweeping reform that risks overwhelming residents with multiple technical changes to planning rules.

A troubled history

The seven local plans enacted in 2006 established detailed rules governing development boundaries, building heights, land uses, urban conservation areas, rural settlements and open spaces.

Their approval followed the 2006 rationalisation exercise, which brought tracts of land equivalent in size to Siġġiewi within development zones. Its consequences are still unfolding, with large swathes of farmland in areas such as Niġret and Qrendi being sacrificed to development.

Labour’s first attempt to replace the plans began in 2013. The proposal envisaged three broader plans covering Gozo and Comino, urban Malta and land outside development zones. The consultation attracted around 5,500 submissions in its initial phase, rising to approximately 6,000 by the end of 2015.

Many sought extensions to development boundaries or changes to restrictions on individual sites. A MaltaToday investigation revealed that in Gozo alone the government faced 500 requests to include ODZ land within development schemes.

The exercise exposed the difficulty of reopening a framework in which landowners have a direct financial incentive to seek changes, while residents often have fewer resources to follow highly technical zoning and height policies.

Abela’s changing position

Abela’s position has evolved considerably over the past years. In June 2021, he argued that the government had its hands tied by the local plans approved in 2006, which had created rights for property owners. Although he had reservations about the original plans, he maintained that the rights they had created could not simply be revoked.

In November 2024, he acknowledged that the plans were outdated and no longer addressed contemporary realities. But he was careful not to prejudge the outcome. He recognised that landowners excluded from development zones would naturally want their property included, while others would seek to reduce existing development zones. He insisted that, ODZ land should not be touched, while identifying building heights, high-rise locations and rationalisation sites not yet rezoned for their intended purpose as issues requiring discussion.

Labour’s 2026 manifesto promises extensive consultation to revise the 2006 plans. It says the exercise must “safeguard land that has not yet been developed” while addressing contradictions in existing local plans to ensure greater uniformity and certainty in building regulations. It also promises to expand some urban conservation areas, introduce buffer zones around them and revise DC15 to give greater weight to aesthetics, building context and volumes.

Speaking on Sunday, 15 November, Abela said the 2006 plans had left a “sour taste” that persisted to this day. Planning policies, he argued, could not remain static while the country evolved. He said he wanted the revision to produce an outcome that would leave people happier and insisted he had a strong mandate to take difficult decisions on planning.

At the same time, he defended the policies introduced in 2015, arguing that it was unfair to criticise them without recognising how they had benefited property owners. Many people, he said, had invested in property and improved their standard of living through rental income. He nevertheless acknowledged the need for a new development control policy to address anomalies and changes since the existing rules were introduced.

The shift is significant: Abela has moved from arguing that the rights created by the 2006 plans could not simply be revoked to advocating a comprehensive review, while continuing to defend the property expectations created by subsequent policies.

What can actually change?

The Strategic Plan for Environment and Development (SPED), approved in 2015, already provides for an appraisal of the 2006 development boundaries. Its Urban Objective 3.1 allows criteria to guide minor adjustments, including both additions to and exclusions from development zones, provided the overall result does not constitute a significant change.

Therefore, residents and environmental groups may seek to remove tracts of land added to development zones in 2006 where no final development permits have been issued. Will government consider reversing such designations after two decades, or will the expectations created among landowners be treated as sufficient reason to retain them?

The government may also exclude an extension of the development zone in the forthcoming exercise but it may still face pressures to extend “areas of containment” where developments like supermarkets and show rooms are allowed in the ODZ.

From DC15 to DC27

One of Labour’s most consequential planning changes was the introduction of DC15 in 2015, which translated building-height limits in the local plans from storeys into metres. In areas designated for three floors, the new limit of 15.4 metres, rising to 17.5 metres where a semi-basement was permitted, could accommodate up to five levels.

Abela has also stated that a new set of rules regulating building heights and depths, known as DC27, will replace DC15 ahead of the local-plan changes.

One issue that may come under discussion is the limit on one-bedroom apartments, generally capped at 20% of the total units in a development. While this restriction may be out of step with demographic changes, including the rise in one-person households, relaxing it also risks increasing density pressures, as has happened in Student Priority Areas in Paola and Msida.

The shadow of the botched 2025 reforms

The review follows government's controversial planning bills of July 2025. Bills 143 and 144 proposed changes to the Development Planning Act and the appeals system, including rules allowing newer planning documents to take precedence over older local plans and powers for an Executive Council to initiate changes involving zoning and building heights.

Environmental organisations warned that these provisions would weaken local-plan safeguards and increase executive discretion. The bills did not complete their passage before the 2026 election.

In May, environmental groups again warned that a comprehensive local-plan revision could achieve some of the same objectives through changes to planning designations rather than legislation.  The question is whether Abela can now be trusted with changing the most consequential planning policy in the country.

From Ħondoq to Marsaskala and Villa Rosa

But government does not necessarily have to introduce entirely new local plans to change existing designations. It can also pursue site-specific, incremental amendments.

For example, Planning Authority is currently considering a request by Pietà Local Council to extend the urban conservation area to the vicinity of the locality’s church, where the historic streetscape is increasingly overshadowed by high buildings.

Other amendments have gone in very different directions. At Ħondoq ir-Rummien, a review initiated in 2023 amended the Gozo and Comino Local Plan to prohibit development on the site, apart from possible afforestation. In Marsaskala, a policy and map relating to a proposed marina were withdrawn from the South Malta Local Plan in 2024.

The unfinished partial review of Villa Rosa in Paceville provides a contrasting example. Launched in 2024, it introduced a framework allowing a hotel of up to 39 storeys and two further hotels of up to 22 storeys, benefiting the site owners.

These cases show that local-plan amendments can remove development potential as well as facilitate major projects. They also underline the need for clear criteria: why should particular designations be changed, and whose interests will determine the outcome?

Residents facing multiple fronts

The proposed review must be considered alongside changes to DC15, the wider development-control framework, individual partial reviews and the planning reforms still being debated. One of the shortcomings of the 2006 process was that, despite years of consultation, the public struggled to grasp the implications of what had been approved.

Residents now face multiple consultations involving technical maps, zoning classifications and height restrictions, often without an easy way to assess their cumulative impact. Landowners seeking to change a site's designation, by contrast, have a clear financial incentive to follow every stage. Residents may only understand the consequences when a development application is submitted or a change has already been approved.

Government must explain how residents will be able to scrutinise proposals and participate meaningfully. More targeted, site-specific changes may be easier to explain and understand than a sweeping reform.

The age of the local plans is not, in itself, a reason to relax planning restrictions. Paradoxically, any revision will have to reconcile two conflicting demands: growing public resistance to the overdevelopment besieging towns and villages, and the need to accommodate an economic model that has itself intensified demographic pressures. Yet the local plans themselves can be part of a process of changing Malta’s economic model.

A meaningful revision should start from the bottom up, asking residents and their local representatives what kind of towns and villages they want to live in over the next two decades. Their vision should shape the planning framework, rather than being squeezed into decisions driven by landowners’ expectations or the demands of the existing economic model.

Ultimately, the test of a new generation of local plans should not be how much development they can accommodate, but whether they can secure better places to live for generations to come.