European Commission calls on Malta to stop finch trapping
The Commission says Malta is using a research scheme to keep recreational trapping going • Government says it will defend the research scheme while protecting the cultural identity and traditions of Malta and Gozo
The European Commission has called on Malta on Thursday to stop allowing finch trapping, arguing that its research scheme for seven wild finch species breached EU bird protection rules.
The Directive it refers to aims to protect birds and their habitats across the EU, as well as halt the decline or disappearance of bird species. Finch trapping can be allowed exclusively under strict derogation rules.
“The Commission maintains that the derogation adopted by Malta does not pursue a genuine research purpose,” the Commission said in its Reasoned Opinion on Thursday. It accused Malta of using the research derogation to continue recreational trapping despite two EU court rulings.
In its own response, the government said it took note of the Commission's formal request and would continue talks on the subjects. It said it would defend the research exemption while ensuring full compliance with EU law and protecting the cultural identity and traditions of people in Malta and Gozo.
In 2024, the European Court of Justice ruled that Malta’s derogation from the ban on bird trapping is illegal.
The Court of Justice of the European Union first ruled in 2018 that Malta’s annual recreational finch trapping derogation breached the Birds Directive. On 19 September 2024, it also ruled against the research exemptions Malta had introduced from 2020. The directive protects wild birds and their habitats and permits trapping only under strict conditions.
Malta went on to allow finch trapping in the autumn seasons of 2024, 2025 and 2026 under exemptions the Commission said were similar to the one the court ruled against in 2024.
The government on Thursday said it had amended the law after the 2024 judgment to address the court’s findings, including by setting out further reasons why it considered there to be no satisfactory alternative.
After the government continued to reopen the trapping season, the European Commission once again launched infringement proceedings against Malta, citing the fact that the newest derogation "does not pursue a genuine research purpose” and effectively reintroduces recreational trapping despite two separate European Court of Justice rulings that declared Malta’s past regimes illegal.
The Commission said the Reasoned Opinion, dated 19 November, aims to challenge the Maltese finch trapping research derogations and address aspects not covered by the Court's ruling in 2024.
"The Commission maintains that the derogation adopted by Malta does not pursue a genuine research purpose and instead inappropriately uses the research derogation for continued recreational hunting despite previous Court rulings."
They said that Malta fails to demonstrate other satisfactory solutions and does not ensure appropriate enforcement.
Malta has two months to reply and address the Commission’s concerns. If the response is unsatisfactory, the Commission said it may refer Malta to the EU court.
Last October, the Government announced the opening date of “research” on seven species of songbirds.
The “scientific research period” covering seven species of finches will open on 20 October and will last until 20 December 2026, inclusive of both dates. Meanwhile, the season for golden plover will run from 1 November 2026 through 10 January 2027
