MAM directives hindering medical progress, Franco Mercieca warns

Parliamentary Health Committee chairman warns MAM directives risk delaying introduction of rapid diagnostic testing in health centres, despite recommendations from a judicial inquiry

The MAM launched an industrial dispute on 20 November (File Photo)
The MAM launched an industrial dispute on 20 November (File Photo)

Parliamentary Health Committee chairman Franco Mercieca has criticised the Medical Association of Malta's directives obstructing the introduction of rapid diagnostic testing in health centres, insisting that patient safety “must always come first.”

In a statement posted to Facebook on Saturday, Mercieca expressed concern over the MAM’s continued opposition to the introduction of point-of-care testing (POCT) and warned that “medical progress cannot be held hostage to industrial disputes.”

POCT technology allows doctors in health centres to obtain key test results within minutes, helping them assess patients' conditions and determine whether they must be transferred to hospital.

Mercieca said the technology could prove particularly important in cases involving potentially life-threatening conditions, such as heart attacks and thrombosis, where timely diagnosis and treatment can be critical.

He also pointed to recommendations made by a board of inquiry into a patient's death in August 2024, chaired by Judge Joseph David Camilleri, which called for such testing to be made available in primary healthcare.

“We cannot, on one hand, call for inquiries to learn from tragedies and identify shortcomings in the healthcare system, and then, on the other, allow the implementation of their recommendations to be stalled without a sound clinical justification,” he said.

MAM directives raise concerns

Mercieca's comments follow a parliamentary health committee meeting held on Wednesday, during which representatives of MAM, Primary Health Care officials, and the chairman of Mater Dei Hospital's Emergency Department discussed the introduction of POCT.

During this meeting, he recalled that the emergency department chairman had highlighted the technology's potential to improve the prioritisation of patients transferred from health centres.

However, Mercieca expressed concern over new directives issued by MAM, with particular reference to the union's decision to maintain previous directives concerning POCT.

The MAM had announced industrial action after a dispute over repeated delays in appointing junior doctors to specialist training posts remained unresolved.

Directives included instructing Foundation Year Doctors awaiting appointment to BST positions not to undertake specialist trainee responsibilities until their appointments are formally confirmed, including through additional rotations or reassignment.

On his end, Mercieca argued that it was “illogical” for the union to raise concerns about the safety of the technology while maintaining directives that hinder the training needed to use it safely.

Addressing MAM's allegations that one of its council members had faced intimidation and victimisation, Mercieca acknowledged that the claims were serious and warranted investigation.

Regardless, he insisted that such allegations should not obstruct the implementation of POCT, which he described as a project of national interest.

While acknowledging doctors' right to raise professional concerns and work in safe conditions, Mercieca argued that logistical challenges should be addressed through practical solutions rather than delays.

He clarified that POCT would not replace emergency department services or justify keeping critically ill patients at health centres. Instead, he said, the technology could help doctors make better-informed decisions on patient referrals without delaying urgent transfers.

Mercieca concluded by urging all parties, including MAM, to prioritise patient welfare and resolve outstanding concerns through dialogue.

“Ultimately, the question we should be asking is not who will win this dispute, but rather what we are doing to provide the patient with the best possible care, in a timely manner,” he said.

“The life and health of the patient must come before everything else.”