Judge, magistrate to face disciplinary proceedings after inquiry into ethics breach

Judicial standards commissioner Toni Abela sent his findings to the chief justice and the justice minister earlier this month, with Abela recommending disciplinary action in both cases and impeachment in one.

Judge Lawrence Mintoff (Left) and Magistrate Donatella Frendo Dimech (Right) have been referred to a judicial disciplinary committee after separate investigations into alleged breaches of ethics.
Judge Lawrence Mintoff (Left) and Magistrate Donatella Frendo Dimech (Right) have been referred to a judicial disciplinary committee after separate investigations into alleged breaches of ethics.

Judge Lawrence Mintoff and Magistrate Donatella Frendo Dimech have been referred to a judicial disciplinary committee after separate investigations into alleged breaches of ethics.

According to Times of Malta, Judicial Standards Commissioner Toni Abela sent his findings to the Chief Justice and the Justice Minister earlier this month. The reports have since gone to the Committee of Judges and Magistrates.

It was reported that the commissioner recommended disciplinary action in both cases and impeachment in one. 

The case involving Mintoff stems from a five-page letter he sent to Cabinet ministers in February, in which he urged them to exclude Prime Minister Robert Abela from discussions and decisions on the appointment of the next chief justice.

Mintoff claimed the prime minister was biased against him. In the letter, previously seen by MaltaToday, he said Abela had summoned him to Castille on 11 February to discuss the appointment and that their conversation later continued on WhatsApp.

The judicial code of ethics bars judges and magistrates from communicating privately with members of the executive about their duties without the chief justice’s consent. The chief justice asked the judicial standards commissioner to look into the matter after the letter became public.

The complaint alleges that Frendo Dimech tried to arrange a meeting between Opposition Leader Alex Borg and a blogger who had been critical of him. “You can come to my place,” Frendo Dimech allegedly wrote in a WhatsApp message included in the complaint, according to Times of Malta.

At the time, Frendo Dimech was conducting a criminal inquiry into cash that had gone missing from a court safe.  Borg’s mother, Mary Debono Borg, serves as director general of the courts where the cash went missing.

The disciplinary committee gives judges and magistrates an opportunity to respond and can hold a private hearing. Sanctions can range from a warning to a six-month suspension.

In cases where there are grounds for removal, the Commission for the Administration of Justice holds a hearing and makes a recommendation to the president.