‘Unacceptable that MPs hide behind conscience’ - AD

Members of Parliament cannot hide behind their consciences but must respect democracy and explain their refusal to honour the will of the people, says Alternattiva Demokratika.

Alternattiva Demokratika chairperson Michael Briguglio today said MPs had to stand by the decision of the people after shiftng their responsibility to decide on divorce onto the electorate.

AD held a press conference down the hill from Hastings garden, where the Sette Giugno celebrations were being held. The event was not open to the public, as police officers stationed around barriers blocked entry to anyone who did not have the proper authorisation or an invite. Members of the press were asked for a press card by the police.

Briguglio said MPs on both sides of parliament were currently engaged in a wrangling war with the media over how they will vote in the upcoming parliamentary divorce vote. “The issue is simple. Over 53% of voters want the introduction of divorce in Malta. Parliamentarians, who did not have the courage to take a decision on divorce and shifted the responsibility onto the people through a referendum, should stand by the result of the referendum,” he said.

“Those who are not ready to vote in favour should resign. Any manoeuvring is simply unacceptable,” Brigulio said..

Briguglio said that AD will be watching MPs carefully and ensure they do on take the electorate "for a ride". He called the way police had cordoned off Hastings Garden "disgusting" and "shameful", and that they had kept common people away from MPs.

AD home affairs and justice spokesperson David Friggieri said Malta was experiencing a Constitutional crisis. “It is unacceptable in a democracy for MPs to simply brush off journalists' questions about their voting intentions. It is equally unacceptable for them to simply refer the population to their conscience, as this creates an irresolvable tension between the democratic process and faith-based reasons which can never be solved through dialogue, an essential component of modern democracies.”

He said that for these MPs faith will always trump any other considerations, including a clear referendum vote, thereby undermining the democratic process itself. “The parliamentarians already acted according to their conscience when they passed the choice onto the public in a referendum. The public made that choice for them, and now they must respect it,” he said.

Friggieri also hit out at the manner in which some MPs, including the Prime Minister, are engaging in what he described as "mathematical democracy". “On the one hand they assured us that the bill will pass because the numbers add up, while on the other they are being evasive about their individual voting intentions.” He said that democracy is not something that is upheld on voting day’ but “must be upheld through a daily democratic institutional system, especially with the media.”

Friggieri also called on the media to keep pressuring MPs on how they plan to vote, “irrespective of what Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi might say is fair or not fair.”

AD international affairs spokesperson Prof. Arnold Cassola said the behaviour of MPs was unacceptable by EU standards, which he said required full transparency and openness from the elected representatives of the people.

He denounced the "coalition of confessional MPs" from both sides who abdicated their responsibilities when they refused to legislate on divorce and shifted the onus onto the people to vote. "GIven that the people have spoken clearly and decided, this irresponsible coalition is trying to deny the people their legitimate rights. Let us not let them succeed in their effort, which goes against the basic tenets of democracy. The will of the people must prevail and any MP who has conscience problems has an honourable way out: that of resigning immediately."

Members of left-wing NGO Moviment Graffitti were also present for the press conference.

avatar
you know what's unacceptable AD? That you preach for conscience-less politicians and that you are effectively trying to blackmail MP's in towing your line by breathing down their neck - so long for tolerance, minority right and the rest of the baggage you preach for - you have lost my trust through such behaviour - granted, you are for divorce - I respect that and I respect the will of the majority to have a divorce law passed through Parliament - but dont ram your dogma (yes, yours is dogma too, just like religious dogma) down MP's throat - I would similarly have criticised those who would seek to coerce MP's into voting no had the referendum on divorce not passed - do you expect someone who professed to be against divorce before the referendum to suddenly change his belief, simply because he is asked to move with the flow?
avatar
The CHurch and 250 000 euros of our money down the drain, read this: https://mazzun.wordpress.com/2011/06/07/flus-flus-u-aktar-flus/
avatar
Those labourites who wish that PL is the antithesis of PN should get real. The only real change comes along if you vote for it, and just like the referendum the only real party which can bring about change is AD. Any die-hard labourite will disagree and still hold on to the notion that PL will bring about change, becuase their identity is depending on that same notion. But all will become real when PL will be in government and everyone will know that it will be no better.....
avatar
eleonoray86cws Ca?uana
Haha, I waste my vote on AD because they are the only true alternative for this crap we have to cope with. The only party with a clear vision, mhux qasab jixxejru mar-rih
avatar
Yes thorny, depends if they get a 500 EUR a week. Everything has its price.
avatar
Luke Camilleri
Apparently even the Nationalist MP's concience is A' La Carte now....
avatar
It is unbelievable and highly unethical of AD of repeating the PNPL mantra when it is clear that the problem is within the Nationalist and not with the Labour Party. I wish to ask AD: would you form a coalition with PN?
avatar
Andre Vella why waste a vote on AD?
avatar
The only option available that I see is vote AD in the next General Election. Why waste a vote on PNPL?
avatar
Rayman Jumbo
It is not my intention to talk about the divorce issue. I want to, however, voice my concern about the fact that a public ceremony on a public holiday to commemorate the Heros of Sette Gungio was blocked off with barriers and hundreds of police and turned into a private function - all becuase the MP's did not want to face Media on the Divorce issue!!!!! Honourable Members of Parliament - if you did not want to face Media questions, you should have blocked the media from attending the event not the public. I, and a few other people, came with the intention to commemorate those who shed their blood for our freedom. I had no plackards, no TV cameras and No microphones. I just wanted to feel proud to see you lay a wreath to those who so much deserve to be rememberd - no more, no less. You should be ashamed of such behaviour - Red & Blue - both of you.
avatar
Nice one, Albert Borg!! May I go a step further and say that at least a penis is a natural organ but the constitution and structure of the Roman church is unnatural, inorganic and harmful in many respects.
avatar
Krista Sullivan
IL KUXJENZA FUQ ID DIVORZJU HI BISS QEDA FUQ IL 500EURO MA TEZISTIEX..............
avatar
AD always received the flank from the PN (the climax being EFA anthics at St. Andrews on the eve of the post EU referendum's general election) - and this because the PN saw AD threatening their absolute majority. Now I sense, even from some commentors, that it is the PL, who are trying to brush off AD, since they may hamper the PL from securing an absolute majority - and worse still an absolute one party cabinet. The fact the Electoral Reforms have been left pending years on end, is an eye-opener for everyone who really wants to see!
avatar
Please stop being stupid about this question - there is no such thing as a minority who voted No. They are just a group of people who deliberately would rather not have the REAL MINORITY (i.e. those with marital problems) to be able to choose about their own life. Their is no right infringement I and for the life of me I cannot see how there can even be a serious debate with these sort of antics and sorry minded people. Get your religion off my democracy, its about high time that people wake up and smell the coffee and we start progressing to become a truly Modern Democratic Secular State. Religion is like a penis, fine to have one and be proud of it, but please don't wave it around in public and above all don't try and shove it down my throat.
avatar
Found somewhere else. AD = Already Dead
avatar
Overall, I agree with AD on this issue but I beg to disagree with a part of their statement referring to the PL as part of a 'confessional coalition'. . @Jason AD will probably remain a very small political party with a constant base of followers, but surely we can say that it has always championed and defended minority rights.
avatar
Conscience is such a versatile political tool for those bunch of opportunists! https://mazzun.wordpress.com/2011/06/06/fejn-hi-l-kuxjenza-ta-gonzi/
avatar
Ghazla wahda hemm ghad-deputati nazzjonalisti - jew jivvutaw kontra z-zieda ta' 500 ewro fil-gimgha tal-ministri u jkunu fuq in-naha tal-opinjoni pubblika, jew jivvutaw favur il-ministri u jkunu kontra l-familji li hadu biss 1.16 ewro fil-gimgha. Il veru test tal kuxjenza nhar is Sibt fil parlament. Nhar is Sibt ha naraw jekk mhux Partit dittatorjali il partit li qieghed fil-Gvern!
avatar
Members of Parliament cannot hide behind their consciences but must respect democracy and explain their refusal to honour the will of the people, says Alternattiva Demokratika. Proset, well said.
avatar
Malajr insejtuhom id-drittijiet tal-minoranzi, tal-Alternattiva! Lanqas rappreżentanza minima fil-Parlament ma tridu li jkollhom dawk li vvutaw LE. Faqqastu minn Partit dittatorjali, u skont iz-zokk il-fergħa għax bħalhom ħriġtu. Tajbin biss għal barra l-Parlament għax lanqas fil-Kunsilli Lokali ma qbadtu art.
avatar
Quote:' He denounced what he described as a “coalition of confessional PN and PL' When will AD grow up? You just keep harping on the collusion between PL and PN which is imaginary. Change your tactics or you will remain just a pressure group ever. Not that I would be bothered, mind you.