Back
Register for SMS Alerts
or enter your details manually below...
First Name:
Last Name:
Email:
Password:
Hometown:
Birthday:
Sorry, we couldn't find that email.
Existing users
Email
Password
Sorry, we couldn't find those details.
Enter Email
Sorry, we couldn't find that email.

Unhappy employers hit out at Equality Bill: ‘Will parties employ people of opposing political beliefs?’

Employers association say they will ‘not be treated as second-class citizens’ in stand against Equality Bill’s burden of proof

matthew_vella
Matthew Vella
14 December 2016, 2:03pm
Civil liberties minister Helena Dalli is spearheading the Equality Bill
Civil liberties minister Helena Dalli is spearheading the Equality Bill
In a libel cases, a journalist has to prove to a court of law that an alleged offence or libellous statement was not, as claimed by the injured party, libellous: the burden of proof lies not with the complainant, to convince the court where the libel exists; it presumes that the libel has taken place and that it should be the journalist to prove otherwise.

Now employers, as well as the Catholic Church – which employs thousands of school teachers – are balking at the Equality Bill’s proposal that employers are presented in court as a guilty party before being given the opportunity to prove their innocence of alleged contraventions of the law.

Malta’s new law is expected to streamline and bolster anti-discrimination laws in employment and other areas, but employers and religious organisations are concerned that the law will remove their power to differentiate in cases where they might feel they want to safeguard businesses’ identities or a religious ethos in schools.

The Malta Employers Association yesterday said the Bill goes “against natural law” since employers would be treated as second-class citizens when faced with a complaint on a contravention of the Equality Act.

“Is this excessive zeal driven by a genuine concern for minority groups, or by electoral convenience and pressure which is being exerted by extremist lobby groups? We are reserving the right to take any legitimate action to protect employers’ rights,” the MEA said.

The MEA said excessive powers are being given to the Commissioner for Equality, who can investigate and take judgement discrimination complaints. “Any person or body accused of discrimination should only be found guilty or otherwise in court after the due legal process, and not by an arbitrarily appointed Commissioner,” the MEA said. “The fact that the original draft of the legislation, which also gave the Commissioner the power and discretion to send an employer to prison without due process, has been amended is of no consolation to employers. The Association added that the provisions of the legislation and the duties of the Commissioner will overlap with provisions which already exist in employment law.”

In a bid to hit out at the implied hypocrisy of government’s proponents, the MEA said private organisations did not have the luxury ministers had to take on ‘persons of trust’, which it termed “an excuse for blatant cronyism and political discrimination.”

“Is government prepared to apply this legislation to its own employment practices, and reassure the tax payer that all employment on the basis of position of trust has been awarded according to the principle of equal opportunity and meritocracy?”

The MEA also stood by the Catholic archdiocese’s viewpoint that it should be able to refuse non-believers from teaching in church schools. “An employer can be accused of discrimination on grounds of ‘personal beliefs’. For example, the church has to give equal opportunity to a non-believer to teach in church schools. This should only be acceptable if the employee follows the institution’s ethos. One has to see whether political parties, for example, are prepared to practice what they preach and offer high positions within their ranks to qualified persons who however sympathize with the opposing party!”

matthew_vella
Matthew Vella is executive editor at MaltaToday.
DealToday
Latest Business News
Business Comment 12:07
US stock market, Samsung Galaxy S9 release date and Adobe’s record revenue
Business Comment 15-12
Siemens AG said Friday that investments in research and development will rise an additional 450 million ($530.6 million) in fiscal 2018 as i...
Technology 15-12
GMO Internet will pay their employees up to 100,000 yen (€756) monthly in Bitcoin
Law Report 15-12
In a judgment delivered on 5 December in Mark Muscat v HSBC, it was held that when one alleges discrimination, one must prove there is ...
Business Comment 14-12
'This is a continuous struggle. Abuse can be limited, but never eliminated. What we need to do is address the black economy and treat it...