To trust or not to trust... that is the question

Now that the PN’s methods were revealed, shouldn’t the party be engaging into some serious soul-searching to redeem our trust?

The PN’s effort to portray the leader of the Opposition as an unprepared, immature boy is on old, stale gimmick.
The PN’s effort to portray the leader of the Opposition as an unprepared, immature boy is on old, stale gimmick.

The main thrust of the PN's current strategy is to divert attention from its internal crisis by blaming it on Labour. Instead, it could have put on a brave face and faced the music. It could have effortlessly succeeded to bury some of its troubles simply because people are too busy enjoying summer.

The latest PN rhetoric claims that Dr Joseph Muscat is an infantile "loudmouth". In spite of denials from the PL, they keep asserting that in 2008 Muscat had an informal chat with Dr Simon Busuttil en route to Brussels where Muscat inadvertently revealed that the MLP intended to turn the Mistra disco debacle into a devastating campaign issue.

Dr Paul Borg Olivier and company are implying that Dr Muscat's alleged carelessness jeopardised his own party's electoral prospects. The PN keeps reiterating that it was Dr Muscat's warning which made it possible for them "prepare" a strong rebuttal.

Frankly, all the hype around this issue raises more questions than answers: one question is, how did the PN prepare itself? Does Dr Borg Olivier mean that they had ample time to spin the web and fabricate better lies on the eve of the 2008 election? Were the methods used by PN legitimate and if not, does the end really justify the means? It surely was not Dr Muscat who was ultimately responsible for coaching Dr Pullicino Orlando and for procuring his fake press card at Television House.

Now that the PN's methods were revealed, shouldn't the party be engaging into some serious soul-searching to redeem our trust? Since the truth has somehow revealed itself, resorting to further below-the-belt tactics will backfire and will further damage the reputation of perpetrators.

To me it is a mystery why key PN exponents keep employing boring tactics like repeating ad nauseam a story that will only achieve one outcome, i.e. confuse and alienate public opinion.

One must add that the PN's effort to portray the leader of the Opposition as an unprepared, immature boy is on old, stale gimmick. Those of you who were raised in the 1980s may remember how the MLP then kept portraying Dr Eddie Fenech Adami as a toddler in diapers in its political newspaper cartoons, simply because in comparison to Dom Mintoff he did not yet have prime ministerial experience.  

Political communication has made great strides ahead since the days of the crass, humorist political newspaper Ix-Xewka. One would expect better from a younger and newer class of experts.

An image of 'baby Joseph' is less likely to stick now that people were alerted to the way the PN operates behind-the-scenes. Whether we like them of not, most of us believe the tell-all accounts of Dr Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando, EU Commissioner John Dalli and Dr Franco Debono. It is only cracks within political elites that enable us to open a window on party war-rooms and to understand some of their internal operations.

One last point. Next time you board an airplane, I suggest you reserve a seat at maximum distance from any politician. Since I have a mouth and I tend to use it, turning mute for the duration of a whole trip is unlikely and most of my onboard conversations are likely to be mere paroli. Hence, I do not wish to lose any sleep worrying about innocent doe-eyed persons in the next seat, who may eventually misinterpret or selectively quote me whenever it suits them.

Dr Carmen Sammut is a media studies academic and chairperson of Labour Party think-tank Ideat.

More in Blogs
Jobs are not an issue, but salaries are
Giving them a fighting chance
Evarist Bartolo
What was that, my Lord?
Michael Falzon
Shocked, are we? Too bad...
Raphael Vassallo
One must rebut that the PN do not have such a hard job "to portray the leader of the Opposition as an unprepared, immature boy"; he is very ably doing it on his own steam. The longer he takes to reveal his plans for Malta and the means he intends to employ in achieving them, the more he exposes himself as puerile and immature. The electorate will hardly put their trust in somebody who has joined the game for personal gratification....who cares about electing the youngest PrimeMinister? How will that ensure our children's future?
Mark Spiteri
Very well said Ms Sammut
I think that most people are happy, because, frankly, Labour have no idea what the hell they're going to do. Yes, the country is badly run, but take a walk to Mscala on Monday evening(!!!!!) , you would be hard pressed to find somewhere to go in for a pizza or a drink. Bars are full, restaurants groaning under the weight of patrons, all armed with top of the line smartphones and ipads and whatnots... As a neutral, i think it is however time for a change.... Apart from a stormy unpopular two year rule in the mid 90s, you do realize that the last time PL had a people's majority was around 1976 do you? Doesn't that point out something? I believe PL will get elected, as being the lesser of two evils....certainly not for e Ideat coming through.
martin mercieca
The only positive thing that came out of this was that PN did not condemn anything from what happened during the Mistragate. They actually tried to hide facts and they boast that they used tactics to hide the truth. I think that nothing has changed to the image of Dr. Muscat but rather it has shown that PN uses any form of tactics to hide the truth and that they are not to be trusted in anything. Secondly a blogger boasted that she heard about this while Joseph mentioned these facts during a party and now we find out that Simon Busuttil infomed the Pn according to what he told him JM during the flight to Malta. They also said that JM hinted the mistragate during a tv debate. So what is the truth? The truth is that gooooonziPN cannot be trusted.
One must remember that this political strategy adopted according to the consultancy of RCC has been working for the last twenty years. The big question surrounding these conniving political shenanigans is very simple. How much longer can the Maltese electorate remain blinkered and oblivious to half truths and fabricated lies by constantly returning this incumbent administration to power over and over again, irregardless of the financial and political instability that is on the verge of bringing down the social obligations of the state so that the cabals can still enjoy their nepotism and financial rewards. One must give a long and hard look to decide whether a personal political favour from their MP’s is worth the austerity measures that will follow with higher taxes and a loss of social dignity when this small island cannot afford to keep its moral and political obligations. The sad truth is that the opposition has not been exactly brilliant in rebutting against this strategy but that is another debate for another day.

Get access to the real stories first with the digital edition