Abortion and shifting sands
But the very fact that her health was put at risk because the law disallows abortion, laid bare the cruel situation women like Prudente are forced into
Abortion remains a politically taboo subject but within society there are signs of a gradual shift in public opinion.
This shift is driven by civil society groups that have shattered the taboo and are publicly and unashamedly advocating a pro-choice stand.
This is not to say that there is a pro-choice majority in the country. A MaltaToday survey in August found that the anti-abortion sentiment still runs high with 61.8% totally against. But it also pointed towards shifting attitudes, especially among the young.
The August survey showed that 27.8% of people are in favour of abortion in particular cases, while a further 8.3% agreed with abortion whatever the situation.
The survey did not ask people to define what ‘particular cases’ they found acceptable but a similar question asked in a more detailed survey on abortion in 2019 found that only 9.2% agreed with termination of pregnancy in the first three months in ‘particular circumstances’. The August findings represented a 19-point increase in three years.
More recently, another MaltaToday survey published last Sunday, found that an absolute majority of people believe that women, who have an abortion should not be sent to prison.
The findings showed that 53.3% of people, up from 46.9% last year, disagreed that women who terminate their pregnancy should be liable to a prison sentence of up to three years.
The results also showed that people are less lenient when it comes to health professionals.
Maltese law criminalises abortion without exception. A woman can be imprisoned for up to three years, while the medical practitioner carrying out the abortion can be jailed for up to four years and lose their warrant.
The law is draconian, making Malta the only country in the EU to have an outright ban on abortion.
This rigidity was severely tested at the start of summer when an American tourist on holiday in Malta, started miscarrying 16 weeks into her pregnancy.
Andrea Prudente was denied an abortion because the foetus still had a heartbeat despite doctors telling her the pregnancy was no longer viable.
Prudente received medical care to avoid the risk of sepsis developing as a result of her condition. She was eventually flown to Spain where her pregnancy was terminated.
But the very fact that her health was put at risk because the law disallows abortion, laid bare the cruel situation women like Prudente are forced into.
The Prudente case forced this country to discuss abortion rights within the context of a real woman whose health was put at risk, and not as a theoretical subject where ethical and human considerations remain aloof from the realities some women face.
In the wake of the Prudente case, Health Minister Chris Fearne ordered a review of Malta’s anti-abortion laws to ensure healthcare professionals are not put in a position where they cannot give women the best of care.
He said this review will not be a backdoor to abortion. It remains to be seen how the laws will be changed but hopefully, any proposal will open up a mature debate that puts women at the centre of it.
-
Court & Police
Accused sent ex-girlfriend 314 messages in two months despite protection order, court hears
-
Europe
Up to 100,000 young people to benefit from new EU–UK mobility deal
-
National
UHM appoints Isabelle Farrugia as first woman chief executive
More in News-
Business News
A Tuesday supermarket trip could bring €10 cashback for Mastercard cardholders
-
Tech & Gaming
Maltese maritime flag makes appearance in GTA 6
-
Business News
Paolo Catalfamo steps down as LifeStar Insurance chairman
More in Business-
Other Sports
Erskine Vella appointed Birgu Regatta Club president
-
Other Sports
Mark Marlow elected vice-president of European Federation for Company Sport
-
Football
Birkirkara FC move closer to their first 11-a-side ground
More in Sports-
Art
Stuta: Austin Camilleri at St John’s Co-Cathedral, Valletta
-
Theatre & Dance
The Nutcracker brings festive magic to Teatru Manoel this December
-
Music
Jazz Assemblea brings Malta's jazz community together in Valletta
More in Arts-
Opinions
Protecting workers’ rights requires cooperation, effective enforcement
-
Opinions
Indispensable yesterday, disposable today
-
Editorial
Why we chose not to publish Adrian Delia’s separation judgment
More in Comment-
GourmetToday
READ: November editions of Gourmet Today and Architecture & Design magazines available to read online
-
Interviews
In conversation with architect David Felice
-
Restaurants
IBER&CO & CASA PEPA: Two ways to love Spain
More in Magazines