Technocrats are not the solution
If such powers of appointment are granted to the Prime Minister, it would effectively mean that our electoral system would be up to a point misleading
Joseph Muscat has become the latest Maltese prime minister to hint at a radical Constitutional reform that would allow for the appointment of unelected technocrats to the ministerial cabinet.
It is hardly an original proposal: indeed, there was considerable debate on this point as recently as 2011, after the leaked US Embassy Cables had revealed that former prime minister Lawrence Gonzi felt hampered by the ‘limited talent pool’ at his disposal.
Dr Gonzi had even pointed out that the Constitution did not allow him the facility to appoint technocrats, since the law stipulates that ministers need to be elected officials.
It may be worth revisiting some of the arguments raised back then. Former (PN) minister Michael Falzon had opined that the time had perhaps come to consider widening the pool to also include unelected ministers.
“Without making any judgements on present members of Parliament, I have already said I was in favour of considering amending the Constitution to allow for technocrats to be made ministers, without being members of Parliament,” he argued. “If countries far bigger than us need technocrats, why shouldn’t we?”
Even across the political divide, the proposal was met with interest. The late Lino Spiteri, a former minister in Dom Mintoff’s Cabinets in the 1980s, likewise agreed that it might be worth discussing whether a “limited number of ministers” could be appointed from outside Parliament.
“They would sit in the Cabinet and the Prime Minister would be accountable to the House for their actions,” Mr Spiteri wrote, adding that Mintoff and Gonzi had both implemented a version of it; Mintoff by having General Workers’ Union members sit in on Cabinet meetings, Gonzi by having (former special envoy to the EU) Richard Cachia Caruana in attendance.
Be that as it may, simple cross-party consensus may not be the only consideration. By definition, Muscat’s express views – quoted in ‘The Maltese Legal System Volume Two, Constitutional and Human Rights Law’, by David Attard – also involve granting the Prime Minister greater powers than those already afforded by the present Constitutional set-up.
Such a move would naturally require Constitutional changes – and therefore the consent of the Opposition – but beyond the formalities and political considerations, his proposal could also open a Pandora’s box.
If such powers are granted to the Prime Minister, it would effectively mean that our electoral system would be up to a point misleading. In our system we vote to elect candidates to Parliament, on the understanding that the Cabinet would be formed from the parliamentary group. By widening the definition of the Cabinet to include unelected officials, we would effectively create a system whereby the people vote for Nationalist or Labour candidates… but have no actual say in the composition of the incoming government.
In practice, it would be a case of ‘voting Joseph (or Simon)’… but ending up with no idea of who you would actually be ‘electing’.
This possibility raises serious questions regarding the most fundamental aspects of our political system. Accountability to the electorate and Parliament is the fundamental basis of a parliamentary democracy; and if this were to be changed, we would end up with a Presidential system of government. (Interestingly, Muscat has also said that he is in favour of increasing the President’s powers… which would also necessitate a change in the way Presidents are appointed.)
Such a system may well have its advantages… but it is considerably different from what we are used to, and in a country with only one house of representatives, it can only seriously dilute the power of parliament – and, by extension, the control of the electorate.
The consequences could be serious. In principle, voters in a democracy should know exactly what it is they are voting for… and, more importantly, should also have the power to remove ministers from office. The beauty of a representative democracy is that the electorate has the power, every five years, to axe a minister or MP who did not perform to expectation. In theory, the people should retain the power to express confidence or clip the wings of MPs. This would not be possible with unelected technocrats, either in theory or in practice.
Moreover, the civil service – starting with permanent secretaries – is supposedly already made up of experts who advise politicians. If the ministries and departments, who must be given all the necessary resources to attract the best talent, employ experts at all levels, there should be no need for a technocrat minister. Moreover, experts are also known to get things wrong. They certainly provide no guarantee against error of judgements or wrong decisions being taken.
Politicians also have other responsibilities beyond leading a ministry competently. A minister should firstly give political direction, while also guaranteeing fairness and transparency: qualities which technocrats do not necessarily have, and do not need to respect if their loyalty is to the prime minister and not to the people.
-
National
SDM ends Pulse's 10-year streak in Junior College
-
Court & Police
Accused sent ex-girlfriend 314 messages in two months despite protection order, court hears
-
Europe
Up to 100,000 young people to benefit from new EU–UK mobility deal
More in News-
Business News
A Tuesday supermarket trip could bring €10 cashback for Mastercard cardholders
-
Tech & Gaming
Maltese maritime flag makes appearance in GTA 6
-
Business News
Paolo Catalfamo steps down as LifeStar Insurance chairman
More in Business-
Other Sports
Erskine Vella appointed Birgu Regatta Club president
-
Other Sports
Mark Marlow elected vice-president of European Federation for Company Sport
-
Football
Birkirkara FC move closer to their first 11-a-side ground
More in Sports-
Art
Stuta: Austin Camilleri at St John’s Co-Cathedral, Valletta
-
Theatre & Dance
The Nutcracker brings festive magic to Teatru Manoel this December
-
Music
Jazz Assemblea brings Malta's jazz community together in Valletta
More in Arts-
Opinions
Protecting workers’ rights requires cooperation, effective enforcement
-
Opinions
Indispensable yesterday, disposable today
-
Editorial
Why we chose not to publish Adrian Delia’s separation judgment
More in Comment-
GourmetToday
READ: November editions of Gourmet Today and Architecture & Design magazines available to read online
-
Interviews
In conversation with architect David Felice
-
Restaurants
IBER&CO & CASA PEPA: Two ways to love Spain
More in Magazines