Millions of euros wasted: the Mater Dei nightmare

Former EU health commissioner finds severe mismanagement inside Mater Dei administration

John Dalli said Mater Dei lost out money on pilferage, overstocking and duplication of medicines.
John Dalli said Mater Dei lost out money on pilferage, overstocking and duplication of medicines.

"What is distressing of the state of play is that there is no rational reason of why Malta's health system - with MDH, currently, the kernel of such a system - is in the level of disarray that it is."

This is how John Dalli prefaces a report into the mismanagement of the €600 million Mater Dei Hospital commissioned by the health ministry earlier in the year.

According to the report, and disconcerting in more than one way, is Dalli's assertion that Mater Dei's financial system was "tantamount to being non-existent", with a one-entry bookkeeping system that is not covered by any accounting policies, no proper books of account, no proper records of amounts due or owing to the hospital, no control of payments made, and no management accounts that could assist management in taking proper decisions. 

"All these are multi-million euro assets," Dalli says, ominously of the fact that there is no effective control to manage yearly hospital operating costs amounting to €230 million; no strategic plans to sustain free health care services; no proper management of yearly contractual obligations amounting to €25 million, and the possibility of double payments to creditors.

Dalli also found:

  • No control over consumption of pharmaceuticals (€14m) and medical supplies (€20m) leading to waste and "out-of-stock" situations;
  • Yearly overtime and allowances amount to €37m; same pay rates for "on call" and "on duty" services by doctors; untaken vacation leave and time-off allowances amount to €3.07m; no management control over payroll costs amounting to €105 million.
  • Unauthorized transfers of high value medical equipment from one location to another; financial records disclose medical equipment at €110 million against inventory records of €67 million.

Information Technology

IT at Mater Dei is "in total disarray". No integrated system, with the government infrastructure of MITA inflicting "dictated policies, introvert attitudes, heavy-handed bureaucracy, obsessive control, and a one-track approach in procurement."

Dalli even found MDH at the mercy of suppliers in accessing patient data.

With the current patient database set to be discontinued by the end of the year because it is outdated, the health ministry now has no alternative but to roll over the contract with the same supplier at a cost of around €2.5 million for a new licence, with an upgrade and a maintenance agreement for a "temporary" period of five years.

Staff and rosters

Data from the salaries section found 534 different shift patterns among 3242 staff, mainly nurses. The shift patterns generate 22 different working hours per week and many workers who have the same duties operate on different shift patterns in different sections at MDH.

"This means that the task of payroll calculation becomes a very laborious and tricky task (20 employees are required to calculate the payroll manually), a lot of disruptions are experienced in the flow of work and overtime is generated to fill the gaps created by these distortions," Dalli said.

"For example, it is a frequent occurrence that operations are not started on time because the full team does not report to work at the same time, and the rest of the team has to wait for the last member to appear. Worst still, it also happens that nurses change during an operation because of roster limitations. Apart from gross inefficiency, this can also affect patient safety."

Dalli also said that management had been further weakened by "interference from political masters who dictated the appointment of people without any consideration of meritocracy, forced staff movements not necessarily on an as-needed basis and who pushed pet vagaries such as family-friendly measures which, though laudable in themselves, were taken to extremes with the absurd results of myriads of unmanageable roasters."

Medical inventory

During 2012, Mater Dei consumed €43 million in pharmaceutical and medical supplies, "without even the basic controls and in a free-for-all environment. This must account for the waste of millions of Euros in pilferage, outdated stocks, and consumption of items at higher prices then appropriate."

Dalli found that apart from the Central Purchasing Supply Unit (CPSU) that manages three stockrooms in Gwardamangia, Madliena and Marsa, there were sub-stores in Mater Dei outside the CPSU's remit.

"There exist in all these stores many months' worth of stock. Everybody tries to have 'just-in-case inventories' so we don't run out. Yet, we still run out [and] end up with many thousands of euros worth of expired inventories."

Out-of-stock pharmaceuticals

Dalli found inadequate computer systems that made it difficult to ensure that medicines were available to patients, without shortages. He blamed government bureaucracy for such problems, such as a purchase requisition taking up to 18 months to get approved.

In an example, he explained how when a supplier is late in his delivery of an order, a tender is issued to bridge the expected medicine gap. Suppliers are asked to quote for this urgent supply, and amongst the tenderers is the late supplier.

"The late supplier who knows the prices quotes a cheaper price. Being the cheapest tender the late supplier is awarded the tender. The 'urgent' tender is also not delivered and no action is taken.

"I would recommend that such a supplier should be blacklisted as his tender offer was a fraudulent one being made when he knew that he could not deliver."

Dalli said that procurement of medicines were placed with a very select group of agents, not manufacturers. "This restricts even further the ability to leverage competitive bids to generate better availability, lower prices, shorter lead-times and better terms and conditions."

Inventory in hospital

Dalli said his visit to the stores in the surgical area was "shocking", finding access open to anyone, concluding that there was excessive expenditure due to pilferage and waste.

Dalli found expensive supplies stored in unsecured rooms; no active implant and instrument inventory on the general surgery side; instrument sterile collections unattended with outside doors commonly left open; and card readers inactivated at the first level security area.

"In short, inventory control is non-existent. This has its genesis not only in inefficient financial management, but also in the fact that there is no proper stock keeping function and system in Mater Dei," Dalli said.

Dalli said that MDH often loaned surgical instruments to private hospitals at no charge; three types of hip replacement implants varying in cost from €700 each to €1,200 but with the same functionality, and maintenance contracts for repairs of some equipment at €2,500 each repair: "When this was questioned, and a cost was requested for a particular repair - equivalent to that contracted - the cost was €750."

avatar
If this is really the state of our hospital then we wish to know who is responsible for these gross incompetencies and they should all be held liable and accountable for their misdeeds. We need police investigations for theft of funds and medicinals.
avatar
The "state of the art" cliche with regards to the Mater Dei hospital refers only to the building and its contents. For the rest, it leaves much to be desired.
avatar
@ George Galea, (1) Dear George, shooting the messenger in no way defuses and minimises the message as edited by Dalli, but compiled by many other independent experts. A picture of complete corrupt abandon of any financial control, sleazy manpower corrupt habits, and laissez faire par excellence! After all dear George, all you need have are a pair of eyes to see it all around you, i.e. even after a short visit to Mater Dei. Of course, after taking off the deep dark blue tinted sunglasses. (2) Moreover it is a complete lie that Dalli was responsible for the building and running of this edifice to corruption and sleaze (just ask the ex President of your glorious party, who had the courage to mention certain matters even before the Whistleblowers Act). An Act so profusely spoken about and of by your party, but of course never enacted. (3) Perhaps you wish to elaborate on Dalli's convictions so as he will clear his name (as you put it). At the same time, please do mention the mighty sniff of political interference and collusion that must have escaped you. You know so your opinion might have some credibility!
avatar
Kindly note that the comments made by Dalli are very general wrt pharmaceutical and medical supplies, "without even the basic controls and in a free-for-all environment. This must account for the waste of millions of Euros in pilferage, outdated stocks, and consumption of items at higher prices then appropriate." This statement is not true when the MEDICINAL is stored in stores, as there is a very high level of security and stock management here. The problem arises once the medicines get delivered to the wards' end, although lately a certain degree of stock control (ALWAYS FOR MEDICINES not SURGICALS!) has been introduced.
avatar
Kindly note that the comments made by Dalli are very general wrt pharmaceutical and medical supplies, "without even the basic controls and in a free-for-all environment. This must account for the waste of millions of Euros in pilferage, outdated stocks, and consumption of items at higher prices then appropriate." This statement is not true when the MEDICINAL is stored in stores, as there is a very high level of security and stock management here. The problem arises once the medicines get delivered to the wards' end, although lately a certain degree of stock control (ALWAYS FOR MEDICINES not SURGICALS!) has been introduced.
avatar
It would be interesting to hear what Paul Pace has to say about this report. Time for Reporter to make the necessary appointment
avatar
It is sad that the honest person who really needs the out of stock chronic medication has to suffer and pay out of their own pockets because of the inefficiency of a few
avatar
Now why should I believe someone who embarrassed my country by being fired as EU Commissioner? Why should I believe someone who still has to give an explanation of his trips to the Bahamas involving millions of Euros? Why should I believe someone was responsible for the running of Mater Dei for 2 years and left it in the sate it is today? Lastly why should I believe someone who was Finance Minister with the responsibility for the building and supply of all medical equipment at Mater Dei and all it's cost overruns (according to Labour)? Mr. Dalli, when you clear your name, if ever, then you can give all us Maltese lessons in Management and moral ethics.
avatar
Any professional accountant worth his salt would not be able to dream up such a horrific scenario in his most frightening of dreams. How could Gonzi possibly state so strongly, whilst chewing on that nasty smirk of his, that "FINANZI (were) FIS-SOD". Only (1) an out and out fraudster would stoop so low; (2) or an utter fool simply used to nice sound bites! (3) Or Lorry&XmunPN taking the mickey outta all the population, including their own fidili!!!
avatar
How they played us all and lied to us all with thier STATE OF THE ART.Realy shame on them.thats what Simon should talk about not the bloody passaporti .
avatar
I wonder how the Foundation for Medical Services fits into all this?
avatar
Once again, the taxpayer picks up the bill for incompetence and non-culpable management responsible for this massive cock-up.