Back
- or -
Email
Password
Sorry, we couldn't find those details.
Enter your email address:
Sorry, we couldn't find that email.
Register with MaltaToday now
Register below to start posting comments, receive SMS news alerts and subscribe to our newsletter.
or enter your details manually below...
First Name:
Last Name:
Email:
Password:
Hometown:
Birthday:
Sorry, we couldn't find that email.

PN challenges Muscat to ‘come clean’ on Mosta roadworks

The Nationalist Party has challenged Labour leader Joseph Muscat to “come clean” on Charles Buhagiar’s involvement in “illegal” roadworks in Mosta.

7 August 2012, 12:00am
Labour MP Charles Buhagiar (left) alongside Labour leader Joseph Muscat.
The Nationalist Party challenged Labour leader Joseph Muscat "to come clean on Charles Buhagiar's €150,000 'mistake'."

This morning, Muscat refused to be dragged into saying anything further than what has already been stated by Labour MP Charles Buhagiar over "illegal" Mosta roadworks he was contracted out to do during the council's adminstration by former Labour mayor Paul Chetcuti Caruana.

The PN explained that Labour MP Charles Buhagiar was entrusted by the Mosta Local Council with major road works in the locality and "made an unpardonable mistake of €150,000 in his projections."

Ever since a board of inquiry issued its report into the council's roadworks, the Nationalist Party has been asking whether Muscat will be taking any disciplinary steps against the MP, who served as the Mosta council's architect.

The inquiry into the Mosta roadworks had found that the work carried out was not in line with acceptable legal and administrative procedures. Buhagair, the project's architect, has denied any wrongdoing on his part and accused the board of not understanding the project because they were not "technical persons."

In a statement issued today, the PN said "When Muscat speaks about accountability, take it with a pinch of salt. He does not mean it; or rather, he excepts everyone to be accountable except his people."

The statement added that "in a typical Labour fashion, [Buhagiar] tried to shift blame on others" and described his behaviour as "absolutely shameful." The PN added "Muscat's priority is defending Charles Buhagair - even if €150,000 from the public's purse have been squandered."

"Why is Muscat so dead set on defending his shadow minister? What is Muscat afraid of? What, exactly, is Labour trying to hide?" the PN asked.

The Nationalist Party challenged Muscat to come clean on this matter and said he owes the public an explanation.

"He needs to say - loud and clear - what action, if any at all, will he take with respect to Charles Buhagiar and his €150,000 mistake."

In 2010, the then Labour council wanted to carry out works in Triq id-Dawr, and turn the street's square into a parking area. Buhagiar has said the Mosta council stood to benefit €390,000 from MEPA's commuted parking payment scheme.

Buhagiar said "I had suggested that Chetcuti Caruana applies for the fund...an application was filed and estimates had been carried out, based on the 2008 tariffs because the contract had been signed during that year."

The MP said Mepa had not issued a permit when roadworks started. "When the new mayor [Shirley Farrugia] ordered a price revision, the roadworks and the works on the square were included as one, with tariffs set at what they are today," he said. "It is a blatant lie that there were not enough funds."

The inquiry found that the council didn't have the necessary funds in its budget and couldn't avail itself of any other funds. The estimate for the roadworks had varied between €187,000 and €330,000.

Buhagiar claims the board of inquiry is made up of "non-technical persons who didn't understand how the project worked."

The board of inquiry also listed several shortcomings in the way the tender for works was awarded.

Asked by MaltaToday last week whether he had ever been awarded direct orders by local councils or whether he had received request for quote for his works, Buhagiar reiterated that local councils had strict regulations to adhere to when it came to the award of tenders.

Buhagiar complained about the fact that he was losing tenders to new and upcoming architects. "They are starting out, they have a small office, sometimes no secretary, and they can afford to provide lower fees. On the other hand, my office employs 11 architects, we have high overhead costs and cannot lower the tariffs as much as local councils would want to," he said.

Buhagiar is currently the architect of three local councils, having lost that of Rabat and Marsaskala. Following a change of local government, he is no longer the architect for the Mosta locality.

gIOVANN DeMartino
Javlin hu l-parir tieghi u tiktibx bil-Malti ghax dizastru ghamilt. Intant x'qal Franco Debono qed issaqsi? Le ma qrajtx x'qal. Ghidilna int. Certissmu li anki INT Javelin, ikollok tirtira.
joseph busuttil
Mela dan demartinu ma jaqrghax xi kieteb Franco Debono, x qal il awditur tal mepa, yellow pages, private jets, xalati fuq jottijiet, €600 fil gimgha, ajjejt nikteb Martinu u dawn skont int "excellent perfomance since 1987. Tahseb li bhal issa Franco Debono mhux izzomm zaqqu bid dahk meta ra xi ktibt int?
peppi x
The way the Nationalists Party put this story, one can take the impression that as a result of a mistake by Mr Buhagiar, we tax-payers had to fork out an extra 150,000 Euro. But reading through the above news item, it seems that what really happened was that (according to the inquiry board - which Mr Buhagiar is querying) Mr Buhagiar underestimated the cost of this project. This is a far cry from the number of projects which costs were underestimated and which were ACTUALLY FORKED OUT by the tax-payer.
peppi x
The way the Nationalists Party put this story, one can take the impression that as a result of a mistake by Mr Buhagiar, we tax-payers had to fork out an extra 150,000 Euro. But reading through the above news item, it seems that what really happened was that (according to the inquiry board - which Mr Buhagiar is querying) Mr Buhagiar underestimated the cost of this project. This is a far cry from the number of projects which costs were underestimated and which were ACTUALLY FORKED OUT by the tax-payer.
mario gellel
MIN HUMA DAWN TA GONZIPN LI QED JAGHMLU SFRATTARIJA FUQ FTIT ELUF TA EUROS (dejjem jekk hu veru), META MA GHAMLUX PROGETT WIEHED LI MA GIEX JISWA ID DOPJU JEKK MHUX IT TRIPLU ????? DAWN GHANDHOM ZEJT F'WICCHOM JEW ??????
mario gellel
MIN HUMA DAWN TA GONZIPN LI QED JAGHMLU SFRATTARIJA FUQ FTIT ELUF TA EUROS (dejjem jekk hu veru), META MA GHAMLUX PROGETT WIEHED LI MA GIEX JISWA ID DOPJU JEKK MHUX IT TRIPLU ????? DAWN GHANDHOM ZEJT F'WICCHOM JEW ??????
mario gellel
MIN HUMA DAWN TA GONZIPN LI QED JAGHMLU SFRATTARIJA FUQ FTIT ELUF TA EUROS (dejjem jekk hu veru), META MA GHAMLUX PROGETT WIEHED LI MA GIEX JISWA ID DOPJU JEKK MHUX IT TRIPLU ????? DAWN GHANDHOM ZEJT F'WICCHOM JEW ??????
mario gellel
MIN HUMA DAWN TA GONZIPN LI QED JAGHMLU SFRATTARIJA FUQ FTIT ELUF TA EUROS (dejjem jekk hu veru), META MA GHAMLUX PROGETT WIEHED LI MA GIEX JISWA ID DOPJU JEKK MHUX IT TRIPLU ????? DAWN GHANDHOM ZEJT F'WICCHOM JEW ??????
Matrix
12th March 1996, could GonziPN please explain if this date has to do with one of their star candidates.
gIOVANN DeMartino
The PN's strongest arguments against PL are 2: Labour's couldn't -be- more-atrocious track record. PN's excellent performance since 1987.
Crispin Camilleri
And the Cost of MDH was that of Lm 80 million, BUT, it finally came to Lm 300 Million. So what's a million there and a million here? Remember this famous quote by a pn official ?
Carmel Xuereb
Dawn bis-serjeta jew il-partit nazzjonalista jitlob lil PL johrog nadif fuq it-toroq tal-Mosta!!!!! Mela vera li l-gemel ma jarax hotobtu ghax il-PN daqs kemm ghandi hmieg xi jnaddaf Alla biss jaf. Dejjem jippruvaw jaqbdu fuq xi tibna u t-travu taghhom ma jarawhx. Se tohorgu xi darba nodfa intom fuq il-Power station, il-kuntratti tat-toroq, id-dizastru ta' toroq li hawn, tridu li l-karozzi jigu tajbin ghat-toroq (dizastru) li ghandna u mhux it-toroq isiru tabin ghal vetturi? U mitt elf haga ohra? Il-veru ma tinbidlu qatt intom tla-PN u issa iktar u iktar ghax tafu li se taqilghu tkaxkira kbira qed taghmlu minn kollox biex it-tibna ta-PL ( li m jistax ikun li ma jkollux xi tibna) tippruvaw tkabruha fi travu ikbar minn taghkom. Bye, Bye,Bye PN.
Dora Buttigieg
"Following a change of local government, he is no longer the architect for the Mosta locality." May I ask the Prime Minister whether this is what he meant when he promised a new way of doing politics? Under this government if you are a Labourite you are not entitled to anything. And then GonziPN made a lot of fuss when Jason Micallef uttered something about employing some Labourites if Labour is elected. It is evident that everything is acceptable in Malta as long as it is done by the GonziPN government!
Dora Buttigieg
What a load of rubbish. The PN is accusing Buhagiar of not adhering to acceptable legal and administrative procedures. Can government lead by example and inform the Maltese tax payer on what acceptable legal and administrative procedures were followed on the 4,000,000 euro commission paid a year ago for a power station that has to be converted from HFO into gas? Can we have some decency please?