Maksar gang trial: Bomb suppliers offered Koħħu monthly €1,500 in hush money

Jury trial of four men accused of the murders of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia and lawyer Carmel Chircop continues with testimony of Vince Muscat il- Koħħu’s father-in-law

Jamie Vella (right) allegedly approached Vince Muscat il-Koħħu’s (left) father-in-law to offer him a monthly sum of €1,500 in exchange for his silence with the police (Photo: James Bianchi/MaltaToday)
Jamie Vella (right) allegedly approached Vince Muscat il-Koħħu’s (left) father-in-law to offer him a monthly sum of €1,500 in exchange for his silence with the police (Photo: James Bianchi/MaltaToday)

Alleged bomb suppliers Jamie Vella and Robert Agius had offered Vince Muscat il-Koħħu a monthly sum of €1,500 if he did not mention them to the police, a court heard on Monday.

Father-in-law to Muscat, Peter Brincat, told the court that while having coffee at a Marsa shop, he was approached by an individual he said was Jamie Vella. Vella had told him he was aware that Vince Muscat was speaking to then police superintendent Keith Arnaud and if he did not mention them, he would be receiving the payment.

Vince Muscat is the star witness in the jury trial, and has been given a presidential pardon to reveal details on the Maksar and Degiorgio brothers’ involvement in the two murders.

Explaining he had eye-problems, the witness said Vella was with someone, who was standing across the street from where they were, but could not identify the second individual.

Brincat said they told him to inform Vince Muscat the next time he visits him in prison.

He was testifying in the jury trial of the four men charged with the murders of Daphne Caruana Galizia and Carmel Chircop will continue Monday morning before Madam Justice Edwina Grima.

The accused are ‘Tal-Maksar’ brothers, Robert and Adrian Agius, Jamie Vella and George Degiorgio.

Vella and Robert Agius, Adrian’s younger brother, are accused of complicity in the murder of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia by supplying the bomb that killed her in October 2017.

Adrian Agius is charged with commissioning the murder of lawyer Carmel Chircop in 2015. Prosecutors insist that the hit was also carried out in complicity with Jamie Vella and George Degiorgio who are accused of executing Chircop’s murder.

All four accused deny the charges against them.

Peter Brincat told the court he was on the fence on whether to inform his daughter, Vince Muscat’s partner, or not. He eventually did, so that they do not approach her.

She had told him to not accept anything, and ignore them.

When Jamie Vella visited the witness for a second time at the same bar, the conversation was short and he informed him they were not interested.

The testimony of former More Supermarkets director Etienne Cassar during the compilation of evidence was also heard in court.

Later this week Keith Arnaud and forensic experts from the Netherlands are expected to testify.

Prosecutors Godwin Cini, Danika Vella and Anthony Vella are representing the Attorney General’s office.

Defence lawyer Nicholas Mifsud is appearing for Adrian Agius, Ishmael Psaila and Amadeus Cachia for Jamie Vella, Alfred Abela and Rene Darmanin representing Robert Agius, and Noel Bianco and Leslie Cuschieri for George Degiorgio.

Lawyers Jason Azzopardi and Therese Comodini Cachia are assisting the Caruana Galizia family, while Vince Galea is assisting the Chircop family.

13:03

That is all for today. Proceedings will continue Tuesday morning. 

A writeup on today's proceedings will be available shortly. 

Thanks for following.

Karl Azzopardi
13:01

Former More Supermarkets director’s testimony read in court

After the prosecution informed the court that witness Etienne Cassar, a former director of Cassar & Schembri with Ryan Schembri was abroad, his testimony during a compilation of evidence sitting in 2021 was read in court. They were partners in the More Supermarkets company. 

He had been asked on whether he knew Carmel Chircop. He was then asked about a Qormi warehouse, and he had explained it was to be used for storage purposes for More Supermarkets.

The witness had explained Carmel Chircop’s name was used for the contract for the space, and he had even forked out €600,000, which was owed to him. The figure was laid out in the contract

Ryan Schembri had fled the country during promise of sale period, and the contract had fell through.

The witness had confirmed the €600,000 was never paid back to Chircop.

Karl Azzopardi
12:29

All witnesses for Monday conclude testimony 

Prosecution tells court all witnesses for today have testified, and foreign court experts, Netherlands Forensic Institute, are expected to testify on Tuesday morning.

Karl Azzopardi
12:21

Vince Muscat instructed friend to make payments in Siġġiewi

Lawrence Pace takes the witness stand. The prosecution’s first question is what his nickname is. “Il-Lolly” he replies.

The prosecution then moves to his relationship with Vince Muscat. He says he knew him since he was a young boy.

He then says he was in Ħamrun, when Vince Muscat approached him and told him to go with him to Siġġiewi. When they arrived there, he told him to hand over an envelope with “around six notes of €50” to someone he did not know.

“I arrived near his car, he lowered his car window, and when I handed him the money, he gave me a receipt,” he tells the court.

Asked to describe the person he gave the money to; he says he barely remembers him. “He was seated and young than me.”

He then describes the second time he was asked to do the same thing. “It was around eight/nine months later, and we did the same thing.”

He also never received a reply as to why he was not the one to hand him the money, when the witness asked why Muscat what the payments were for.

Karl Azzopardi
11:45

We are back inside 

We are back in the courtroom and the session resumes. 

Karl Azzopardi
10:51

Rental service owner takes witness stand

Jason Camilleri, who used to operate car rental service Jason’s cabs, in St Paul’s Bay, takes the witness stand.

He had rented a Peugeot car to Robert Agius. He says when spoken to by inspector Keith Arnaud, he had been asked on his relationship with Agius.

Camilleri tells the court he knew Robert Agius for around five years. “He used to rent a lot of cars from us. He used to rent a car for his mother, he used to rent a car when he took his personal car for service.”

He also specifies that Robert Agius always dealt with him directly.

After questioning from the prosecution and the magistrate, he clarifies Agius never asked for a specific model.

He is cross-examined by a defence lawyer, and clarifies the police never requested he hand over CCTV or documents related to Robert Agius.

The court breaks until 11:30am.

Karl Azzopardi
10:35

Brincat is cross examined

A defence lawyer asks him to confirm that he is Vince Muscat’s father-in-law. He is also asked whether his daughter was already receiving money from “maybe someone like Melvin Theuma”. He replies by saying he was not aware of anything.

Brincat is also asked, and clarifies, details of the meeting between him and Jamie Vella. The defence lawyer also wants to confirm he did not know Vella prior to the meeting, and when he later was asked to identify him at the police depot, could not remember his identity.

Karl Azzopardi
10:28

Vince Muscat’s father-in-law takes witness stand

Peter Brincat takes the witness stand and says that when taking coffee at Rob’s Bar in Marsa in the morning, Jamie Vella entered the establishment.

He says Jamie Vella approached him he would be willing to give him €1,500 a month if he told his daughter, who was Vince Muscat’s partner, to tell Vince Muscat to not say anything to Keith Arnaud.

Brincat says he was later asked to go to the police depot and try and identify Jamie Vella, but he could not, due to his short-sightedness.

Karl Azzopardi
10:04

Assistant police commissioner Malcom Bondin takes witness stand

He testifies that he was asked to observe a Haz-Zebbug garage. Inside a revolver was found. The assistant commissioner tells court he delivered the arrest warrant for Adrian Agius after spotting him near the garage.

Karl Azzopardi
09:56

Santa Venera apartment owner takes witness stand

Ruth Chircop, the owner of the Santa Venera flat where the accused had regrouped after killing lawyer Carmel Chircop takes the witness stand.

She tells the court the police had requested a list of who she had rented out the flat, and she did. Jamie Vella was as a person of interest listed by her.

In late 2015 she had rented it to Jamie Vella.

“The place was new, and I had listed the place, and a real estate agent came back to tell me a couple was interested. We had organised an appointment, we spoke a bit, and we decided he can rent it out,” she says. “The apartment was rented out for a year, and he had told me after he wanted to rent it out for a couple more months.”

The reason for Vella renting out the maisonette, the witness was told, was that he was house hunting and wanted to rent in the meantime.

She is asked to identify Jamie Vella in the court room, and proceeds to point at him.

Karl Azzopardi
09:32

Forensic expert takes witness stand

Forensic expert and police officer Patrick Farrugia takes the witness stand. He is speaking about swabs carried out on organic material found at the crime scenes. Farrugia explains to jurors difference between wet and dry swabs.

Karl Azzopardi
09:21

Good morning. We are inside the court room. Proceedings begin.

Karl Azzopardi