MEP Louis Grech writes to Almunia to ‘allow granting of vital support’ to Air Malta

Labour MEP and former Air Malta chairman Louis Grech tells European Commission to consider aid package that “ensures vital support” for ailing Air Malta.

Grech, who served as Air Malta chairman under both Labour and PN administrations between 1996 and 2003, has called into question the European Commission's decision for having turned down the Maltese government’s proposed capital injection to enable the airline to rebuild its capital resources.

"I am at a loss as to why the Commission turned down the proposal EU approval of a capital injection... The ultimate aim was to return the airline to profitability and enable it to operate competitively in the market without any State support, as has been the case so far,” Louis Grech said.

Grech has formally written to the European Commission Vice-President Joaquin Almunia, to stress the need for his ‘consideration’ of an aid package that is in full respect of EU state aid rules and that “ensures vital support” for the airline.

He blamed “hard times as a result of a new, harshly competitive environment” as the reason for Air Malta’s current crisis, and explained that while such circumstances have broken ‘many an airline’, Air Malta has used its internal resources – not taxpayers' money or subsidies - as has been the case with a number of EU carriers.

According to Louis Grech, the main problems affecting Air Malta’s current performance are tied to hiked fuel prices, fluctuating exchange rates, the economic recession and cut-throat competition.

Grech stressed that Air Malta has not been the recipient of any State Aid, not only since EU membership, but even before that.

“On the contrary, it has been Air Malta which has subsidized, and indeed continues to subsidise, tourism and air transport development through its marketing activities, with an annual expenditure of around 25 million.

“It is rather ironic that it is exactly this development which has permitted low-cost airlines to find fertile ground for their own forays into the market,” Grech said.

While stressing that Air Malta is fundamental to Malta’s communications infrastructure given its peripheral island status, throughout its history, Air Malta has provided and still provides service on routes and airports that are either not served  at all, or are not adequately served, rendering a much needed public service, even by low-cost airlines benefitting from Maltese government marketing support,” he said.

In his letter, Louis Grech stressed on Air Malta’s role as the provider of the “best, expedient and most practical means of transport for the ordinary Maltese citizen wishing to leave the island, not to mention its crucial services during the off-peak tourist season when other airlines withdraw capacity completely.

While also mentioning the vital role Air Malta plays for the Maltese manufacturing industry, Louis Grech stressed that “were it not for Air Malta, the Maltese economy would have faced severe crises whenever other foreign airlines, including legacy ones, decided at short notice to withdraw from the Maltese market.”

avatar
@jerry - the issue with Louis Greach was not the golden package. It was that AirMalta did not even know the full extent of Louis's package - then you wonder if the company was mismanaged. This is the real story behind Mr Grech time at AirMalta. Read up! http://archive.maltatoday.com.mt/2004/01/04/t6.html
avatar
@salgister - i think you are agreeing all by yourself that problems started after Louis Grech left. You are also ignoring the reality of low-cost airlines such as Ryan Air and the fact that we are in the EU and cannot stop EU companies from doing business in Malta - no more than they can stop their citizens betting with Malta based betting companies for example - so don't think we are the victims here for a minute. And anyone saying - no workers must be fired. That is like being very sick and refusing treatment. Painful and unfair decisions will have to be made. It's too late now - you can bury your head in the sand or you can argue that somebody should bail out the airline and pay for its mistakes. There are two separate issues here A)- who is responsible for this fiasco - low cost airlines are not responsible for this fiasco, they are simply the reality that a competently managed airline should have dealt with. B) What shall we do now - and this is really what my post is about. Do you really think that Malta can afford to carry the burden of a failed airline. Have you actually check how very few workers are actually carrying the burden on this country on their shoulders ? And i don't mean the thousands of people working within the bureaucracy and adding only burden and cost on the shoulders on the real money earners - the ones that generate wealth, not count it, tax it and or get bribed with it. And off course an Airline is of strategic importance and that tourism is VERY important coz the money that industry creates is REAL money - actual generation of wealth. But think for a minute - what would you rather have? an expensive airline with a few passengers and hotels, bars, restaurants mostly empty or low cost airlines ferrying vast numbers of tourists over - even if this airline is not AirMalta. And what about all the other industries - all the people who travel on business (and i don't mean the Brussels xalata bus). Do you think operating in a micro economy and then having to pay more for everything compared to your foreign competitors - do you think this is a good business model? So please - stop whining and wishing we can solve this problem without making changes. Let AirMalta behave like a privately owned business and do what is right for the business - in a free market economy so that passengers have freedom of choice. Get it in your heads - government is the problem. Labourites arguments always come down to 'when we did the exact same thing but with our people - things worked out better'. So basically they have nothing new, nothing different and nothing fresh to offer. Then you wonder why despite of all the corruption and systematic rape of the economy that goes on in broad daylight - labour still manages to loose the election.
avatar
Micheal Bonanno
@Apollo. Everybody is concurring that the trouble for AirMalta started after Louis Grech's departure from his chairmanship. In fact 2004 is the year stated when trouble started for the company. But the trouble started with the purchasing of RJ70's and Azzurra Air! Trying to throw mud on a person who helped the company develop more is abhorrent!
avatar
Lino Camilleri
You are right martin POLITICAL APPOINTMENTS = YES MEN. But remember they are both gaining.
avatar
@jerry Sorry to draw your attention but we are not creators of God but God's creations or creatures. Otherwise I agree entirely with you that whilst we get peanuts the monkeys at helm got €600
avatar
If one recalls well since its inception under a labour government appointments were not political ones like they have been for the last twenty years or so, Albert Mizzi could not be called a red blooded socialist. All was going well even for sometime under a nationalist regime, untill political appointments became the fashion, were it's not what you know but whom you know. The problems started when in order to get support for our entry into the EU we went and bought half a dozen Avros RJ 70 that nobody needed and which are fuel guzzlers and continued to ruin everything by the Transavia partnership. Despite the restructuring in 2004 AirMalta still suffered heavy loses and all this due to mismanagement, when you have a political appointee you only get a YES man and nothing else who can hardly be described as his own man.
avatar
Lino Camilleri
@ citizenX Can you name one person who was and or is in a high position who do not have a golden package. Remember that you (I think) have been given an increase of €1,16c per week while the govt. ministers have been given an increase of €600 euros per week. We are all creators of God. Aren't we
avatar
As long as you see the world in red or blue - you will never get anywhere. Try seeing the world in right or wrong for a change. Louis Grech is part of the culture that lead AirMalta to its current state - a captive market being overcharged and the company instead of building up its strength, was systemically raped and funds siphoned off. Louis Grech has the business skills of a 3 year old - his main skill has been looking after his own interest and his own pocket. The situation now has changed - we are in Europe and no longer can AirMalta treat Maltese citizens as its private cash-cow. Now it has to compete and its been found to be totally unprepared. Want to discuss the merits of Louis Grech - let's discuss how much money he took from AirMalta and how he managed to hide the true size of his compensation package. Then we can see how he is different from all the other PN con-men that have acted in the same way. Well Louis is following a well trodden path in the Maltese media - taking the opportunity to redeem his record and brush over the corruption, theft and incompetence that characterized his time in office. Recent similar episodes were articles from ex CEOs of Enemalta and Lotteries&Gaming. I guess adding 'opportunistic ass-hole' to their resume is to be expected from these gentlemen.
avatar
Salgister, get your facts right. Air Malta started to lose money in 1998 - the moment Mr Grech took over. Under the previous chairman, RJs and all, Air Malta registered huge profits year after year -LM10million in around 1994. It is very noble of Mr Grech to petition Mr Alumunia, and what he says is correct. Air Malta is a victim of our own government's EU approved donations to low-cost carriers. The situation is untenable. LCCs have been benefiting from subsidies for the last 5 years. EU gives permission for that. Rather than opearting new routes, these companies have operated from airports close to where Air Malta operates and killed their market. Furthermore, Maltese are using them for their holidays, further killing Air Malta's miniscule home market. Yet it still carries 55% of all passengers to Malta (giving a lifeline to the Maltese economy), all unsubsidised. LCCs have lowered the airfares so much that Air Malta ends up carrying passengers at a loss, because it is disadvantaged by its own shareholder. Well done Mr Grech, Your efforts are appreciated.
avatar
Thankyou for your support in such difficult times.
avatar
Jessica Chetcuti
I'm trying to figure out if 4aBetterf-MT is serious or just a wind-up merchant......Never the less if he is serious then he has absolutely no idea what he is talking about. I'm sure that Louise Grech doesn't consider himself as a Maltese hero just for asking the EU for the capital injection that Air Malta so badly needs...... I'm sure that he has only the airlines future at heart. When you consider that the fate of Air Malta could be in the hands of some pen-pushing nonentity in Brussels then you really start to worry. All our MEP's should be voicing their concern in unison There is no good going into the demise of the Hal-Ferh, Selman Palace and the Holiday Inn, but suffice to say that they did not belong to Louise Grech, (who was however partly responsible for their creation), but were part of the airline group of companies. What "salgister" wrote is absolutely correct.
avatar
salgister you are perfectly correct. The fact that 4aBetter_MTwants to pput the blame that squarely belongs to the PN incompetents on Louis Grech shows that they are ashamed of their own incompetence and wants to put the blame on others. As they say, their face and the other place where the sun never shines (or is supposed not to shine) are the same.
avatar
Lino Camilleri
You are right salgister. Air malta was in a state of excellency under Louis Grech. One should note that nearly all parastatal companies which were created under the mlp took the slipping road under the pn administrations. It is not a coincidence sure.
avatar
so you think,that noone knew nothing in reality from both parties? all has been hidden from the public- they both new these things- Wow they are opening their mouth just now, about how much losses etc..!!!!! it's all a setup-
avatar
Micheal Bonanno
@4Better_MT. You're totally wrong. Air Malta went into the red after Louis Grech left. In fact, Air Malta was regressing after Mr. J. N. Tabone took it under his wing (pun unintended)! After the disaster of the RJ 70's and Azzura Air catastrophe, Air Malta was a downhill drive to bankruptcy.
avatar
Air Malta made huge losses under Louis Grech, so it's quite ironic that he thinks that he's the Maltese hero by sending off a letter to the Commissioner. A tad too late isn't it?? Trying to pick up some votes... Would be nice if the Opposition recognised the gross mismanagement which led the national airlineto lose hundreds of millions of taxpayers money (yes, all the assets which Air Malta sold off over the years belonged to the Government and therefore to the people... What's with the bull that Air Malta never received any help?? Who did Tal Ferh and Selmun Palace belong to?---- Louis Grech and his accolytes??) Opposition should make itself useful and stop excusing past mistakes and look to the future: if they are serious about running the country they should start working hard on a Future, Restructured, Efficient and Profitable Air Malta cause we want our money back!!!
avatar
An excellent letter that ticks all the boxes. The economy of an island economy depends on effective links with key commercial centers. The market will cherry pick and it has to be air malta to bring together a holistic set of destinations that will underpin Malta's competitiveness. those who will ignore this simple fact will do so at our own collective peril. It is of course equally obvious that our Airlines has to be run as efficiently as is possible.
avatar
Tal Hamrija Air Malta is only ion dire straits because of extremely bad mismanagement by incompetent politically appointed management by the PN. We must do whatever is necessary to save Air Malta and to hell with what the EU says. If they don't like it they can shove their opinion up their ****
avatar
Michael Gauci
Go on and throw more millions into the black hole.It's only money anyway and it is not yours in the first place so why worry?