Eurocopter accuses AFM of tweaking tender document to suit Italian rival

Armed Forces accused of changing helicopter specifications for patrol boat designed by Augusta Westland sister company, to suit Augusta's helicopter bid.

The AFM's 'Diciotti' class P-61 patrol boat. Photo: AFM
The AFM's 'Diciotti' class P-61 patrol boat. Photo: AFM

Government may be facing calls to launch an investigation into allegations that the Armed Forces of Malta "tweaked" the specifications of a €58 million tender for the provision of military helicopters for the Armed Forces.

The tender has so far been put on hold on the strength of a decree issued this week by Mr Justice Joseph Zammit McKeon, who upheld a request for a prohibitory injunction by military avionics manufacturer Eurocopter, who pointed out what it described as "anomalous" and "unlawful" changes in the specifications of the tender, to suit rival bidder Augusta Westland SpA, a subsidiary of the Italian firm Finmeccanica.

The unlawful changes pointed out by Eurocopter are said to be "identical" to what has so far been discovered by Italian police a week ago, who arrested Finmeccanica's most senior officials for allegedly bribing Indian officials in a tender for the procurement of military helicopters.

As was the case in India, the anomalies flagged in Malta are related to the tweaking of specifications in the take-off weight of the helicopters, which when compared to Eurocopter, allegedly suit Finmeccanica and its subsidiary supplier Augusta Westland.

It transpires that the Maltese contracts department had written to Eurocopter four days after the tender was issued, saying it had made 'formatting' changes to the first page of the tender document, which after a cautious analysis turned out to be a dramatic change in the maximum take-off weight of the helicopters.

The change was noteworthy to Eurocopter, who immediately pointed out that the change was deliberately made to accommodate Augusta Westland whose helicopters were heavier.

When Eurocopter wrote to ask questions about the change in the document, both the contracts department and the AFM replied that they "knew nothing about it" - a legal document sent by Eurocopter's lawyers and seen by MaltaToday shows.

Additionally, Eurocopter have pointed out that the AFM's only patrol craft with a helipad is the 'Diciotti' class P-61 vessel, which was delivered in 2005 and built by Fincantieri - Finmeccanica's marine arm - and a sister company to Augusta Westland. This led Eurocopter to suspect that the change in tonnage was meant to put Augusta Westland as the definite beneficiary of the contract.

Additionally, the P-61 vessel was financed by the fifth Italian financial protocol to Malta, and the fact that Finmeccanica is owned by the Italian state serves to raise eyebrows about the way the tender may have been adjusted to suit "political obligations" towards Italy.

In their submissions to the law courts, Eurocopter pointed out that since August 2011, the AFM were known to be considering a helicopter with a maximum take-off weight (MTOW) of five tonnes, in order to allow seaborne operations and integration with its marine craft P-61.

Eurocopter spared no words in alleging that changes to the tender document when tendering was already underway were "drafted or modified in a way to tailor the bid for specific bidders and consequently lead to the exclusion of others."

Only Eurocopter and Augusta Westland bid for the AFM tender issued last September, 75% of which will be financed by the Europea Union's border control budget.

But Eurocopter was informed that they were being "administratively disqualified" from the process last month, on the basis that their objection to the changes did not go through the right channels of redress, and that their submission was technically wrong because the financial package was included in two CDs and not in one.

Eurocopter have initiated legal proceedings against the Maltese government seeking redress for their omission from the tender process, and will be filing for damages in the days to come.

"their submission was technically wrong because the financial package was included in two CDs and not in one." Is this a joke? :-)
When will thje electorate realise that to win a tender during a PN administration the most important asset is being a member of the cocktail party circle
Seeing all this graft and corruption enveloping the whole Government operation like some nuclear fallout, would you blame the AFM for trying to rope in some of the juice? Who would blame them?
Apparently, there are 3 topics you don't discuss ion Malta; Religion, politics, and tender of naval assets. Welcome to the EU. Why did we vote to join? Oh, I remember, to join the rest of Europe in a strong union of economic and political parity...and corruption.
Well! Well! Well! Fincantieri management has been accused of corruptions regarding the consignment of helicopters to India. Certain high echelons of our armed forces/ Govt must be implicated in this other case of corruption. Come on let us get rid of these people who have stolen our money for years. Mr Gonzi GAME OVER.
..... xejn gdid my friend .... taht gonzipn kollox possibbli ..... nahseb li minn hawn u ftit iehor jekk jibqa' gonzipn anki tender biex nipprovdu l-haxix biex jiekluh il-bebbux li hemm fil-gonna tal-gvern tibda tigi mbabsa biex jirbhuha l-hbieb tal-hbieb .....
Yet another case of corruption at the highest level for sure, identical to changes made to accomodate BWSC to create the filth and asthma in our air that we breathe and in line with the oil corruption scandal. And who is politically in charge of the Contracts Department. None other than our Star Tonio Fenech who has recently also excelled at character assassination of the very worse kind. Could some wife of Finnmeccanica have endeared herself to our Star as to give him another watch or clock.? The corruption in our air that we breathe is increasing daily