A disappointing performance
By refusing to give any clear answers to specific questions, both Vella and the Commission president have sent out ominous and ambiguous messages regarding the future of European legislation.
Commissioner-designate Karmenu Vella’s performance at last Monday’s European parliament hearing has been met with mixed reactions.
Environmentalist groups and the European Greens unanimously expressed disappointment and frustration at Vella’s refusal to commit on any policy directions, or even to adequately answer many of the environmental committee’s detailed questions.
On a political level, however, Vella drew moderate praise from his own allies, the Socialists, and also the European People’s Party: which includes the Nationalist MEPs, who are all pre-emptively committed to supporting Vella’s bid.
This polarity of opinion is worrying. Vella has been proposed for the environment, fisheries and maritime policy portfolio. All three areas are extremely vast and sensitive, and require in-depth knowledge of the subject, and above all need clear policy directions from the outset.
Fisheries in particular is mired in serious conservation issues and allegations of corruption at national level. Maritime policy is responsible for the employment of millions of Europeans. And as Eurobarometer surveys have consistently shown, the environment as a whole is an area on which the overwhelming majority feel very strongly, and believe that not enough is being done at European level.
The point of these hearings was therefore to reassure the European Parliament – and, by extension, the European voter – that the incoming Commission had a clear vision for the future development of European policy in all such areas. Indeed, laying down such policy direction is the fundamental purpose of the European Commission, which is expected to draw up the policies upon which European directives – which are subsequently drafted into national legislation – are based.
From this perspective, Vella’s point blank refusal to commit to any policy direction was disappointing. Moreover, he proved reticent even on the one issue with which he has already been tasked: i.e., revising the Wild Birds and Habitats directives, which is of particular relevance in the light of the Malta’s hunting and trapping record.
Nonetheless – and perhaps unsurprisingly – Karmenu Vella was at his best by far on maritime policy, which has immense implications for the ‘blue economy’: i.e., jobs and economic activity related to coastal areas and the sea. This is an area in which Vella has acquired considerable experience in his tenure as tourism and economy minister. Clearly, his answers on the issue of sustainable job creation in the maritime sphere went down well with all parties concerned.
But on both the environment and fisheries he came across as poorly prepared and often unaware of the issues he was being asked about. His responses were variously described as “vague, evasive and often inaccurate”, “naïve”, “unsatisfactory”, “non-committal” and “unconvincing”.
Pieter Depous, EU policy director at the European Environmental Bureau, summed up many reactions by declaring: “Either Vella was not allowed to make any commitments during his hearing or he did not have sufficient knowledge to do so. Either way the conclusions for the Environment Committee should be crystal clear. They cannot let him pass if they want the European Parliament to be taken seriously in the next five years.”
Yet the ENVI committee has already given Vella the green light for an almost certain acceptance today. This in turn suggests that the political factions represented in the European Parliament are motivated not by satisfaction with Vella’s environmental policy ideas – in fact he appears not to have any – but by political considerations which override the exigencies of the portfolio which he has been given.
Naturally the European Socialists have an automatic interest in approving a candidate nominated by one of their own member parties: especially in the context of a Commission under the presidency of an EPP veteran, Jean Claude Juncker, and in which Socialist Commissioners will be a minority. The EPP, on the other hand, is understandably keen to vindicate the questionable portfolio choices made by Juncker: who has already been criticised for relegating the environment to the backburner, and placing sensitive policy areas in the hands of Commissioners from the countries with the worst infringement records.
But neither is a very good reason to approve a Commissioner who will be responsible for European legislation on extremely sensitive matters. Surely, the job ought to go to the candidate with the best credentials and the clearest vision in those particular sectors. Karmenu Vella failed to convince some of the key stakeholders that he has the knowledge, insight and initiative to take on these problems. The upshot is that the incoming Commission shall not be approved on the basis of its expertise and vision in the key areas it will regulate; but rather, on the basis of political horse-trading between the largest political groupings in Europe.
To be fair, one must also give Vella the benefit of the doubt. Time will illustrate the extent of his actual commitment to addressing many of the problems of his portfolio. But by refusing to give any clear answers to specific questions, and above all by maintaining a non-committal attitude to some of the more pressing problems associated with his portfolio, both he and the Commission president have sent out ominous and ambiguous messages regarding the future of European legislation.
This does not bode well for the Juncker Commission’s declared aim to ‘restore faith’ in the EU.
-
National
Labour MP Nigel Vella seeks breach of privilege ruling after Joseph Farrugia dubs him ‘clown’
-
National
Scammers offer discount on fake traffic fines in fraudulent messages
-
Court & Police
Student charged with grievously injuring man in Paceville fight
More in News-
Business News
The new face of financial fraud
-
Business News
EY National Tax Conference revisits the history and evolution of taxation in Malta
-
Business News
TradeMalta: Creating lasting value for Malta-based businesses
More in Business-
Other Sports
Erskine Vella appointed Birgu Regatta Club president
-
Other Sports
Mark Marlow elected vice-president of European Federation for Company Sport
-
Football
Birkirkara FC move closer to their first 11-a-side ground
More in Sports-
Music
Filgħodu: Singer-songwriter Philip Vella celebrates love in life’s simplest moments
-
Theatre & Dance
MADC’s Peter Pan flies into Teatru Manoel this Christmas
-
Art
New exhibition explores millennia of encounters and worship at tas-Silġ
More in Arts-
Opinions
I am Jane Doe
-
Opinions
Creativity is dangerous, especially when it’s missing
-
Editorial
Malcolm and Clyde: Of ghosting and ghost reports
More in Comment-
GourmetToday
READ: November editions of Gourmet Today and Architecture & Design magazines available to read online
-
Interviews
In conversation with architect David Felice
-
Restaurants
IBER&CO & CASA PEPA: Two ways to love Spain
More in Magazines